Star Scrapbook: Jyll Everman Save Collection Share Flip through a Food Network Star finalist's scrapbook for an up-close-and-personal look at journal entries and snapshots taken inside the Star house. 1 / 20 Midwestern Gal Jyll Everman, a bubbly caterer from California by way of Wisconsin, made it to the top six. She was the first finalist sent home from New York City.