People consistently enjoyed the buttery flavor and texture of the cookies. Many praised the simplicity and delicious outcome of the recipe, highlighting that it comes together beautifully when made as directed.
Several people shared successful substitutions and modifications. Common suggestions included using 3 sticks (3/4 pound) of butter instead of 3/4 cup, adding extra ingredients like flour, water, milk, eggs, and chocolate chips to achieve desired consistency, and incorporating flavors such as almond extract, lemon zest, and various types of chocolate.
The recipe was frequently used for holiday events, especially Christmas, as well as tea time and bake sales. People enjoyed making both cutout shapes and log/slice versions for these occasions.