People loved the crunchy topping and the overall delicious flavor of the dish. Some noted the soufflé-like texture with a hint of vanilla.
Many people substituted ingredients to suit their taste preferences, such as using brown sugar instead of granulated, adding cinnamon or nutmeg, using half the sugar, and even adding oats or marshmallows to the topping.
This dish was frequently used for Thanksgiving and Christmas, becoming a staple for holiday dinners.