Choosing the Right Type of Tuna

Water or oil-packed? Canned or fresh? Chunk light or albacore? There are lots of options when choosing your tuna. Here are tips to guide you through your next restaurant visit or shopping trip.
We've featured lots of tuna recipes this week, but now we want to go back to basics: choosing between the different types. There are so many options -- water or oil-packed? Canned or fresh? Chunk light or albacore?
Canned Choices

Water and oil-packed canned tuna are both delicious (especially the fancy imported kinds packed in olive oil), but all that oil jacks up the fat and calories. Oil-packed has about three times more fat than water-packed does. Water-packed is best for everyday use, and only use the oil stuff for smaller portions -- say, sprinkling a small amount over a large salad to share with dinner guests. (Draining some of the oil off will also help.)

Your other canned tuna choice involves the type of fish; white albacore and chunk light are the most common. White albacore is a larger fish and, when canned, has a meaty texture with a mild flavor. Chunk light tuna is a smaller species of tuna; when canned, it has a softer, flakier texture and can have a stronger flavor.

The calories are about the same for the two (white tuna has about four more calories per ounce), and each has about 20 grams of protein per three-ounce serving. Because it’s a larger fish, albacore is higher in heart-healthy omega-3 fats but it’s also higher in mercury, which can be toxic in large quantities. (We have more on the dangers of mercury here.)

I use both kinds of tuna for different types of recipes. Firmer albacore tuna stands up better in dishes like my Tuna Pasta Salad. Chunk light works when tuna is your main ingredient. When prepping a large batch of tuna salad, I use a can of each to up the omega-3 fats while keeping the mercury levels lower.

    Recipes to try:
Fresh Tuna

If you're a sushi fan or like to grill up steaks, this is what you want. When choosing, the main thing to consider here is the size of the fish and the mercury amounts. As a general rule, the bigger the fish, the more mercury in it. Some of the larger, highest-mercury varieties include bluefin, bigeye, yellowfin and albacore, but yellowfin and albacore have half as much mercury as the bigeye. It gets even more confusing -- both bigeye and yellowfin tuna are commonly referred to as “ahi tuna.” You may want to ask your server to specify next time your place your sushi order.

According to Gotmercury.org, a 150-pound person can eat two and half to three ounces of bigeye tuna per week and keep their mercury exposure within safe limits. If you eat fish multiple times a week or are pregnant, you may be better off sticking with the lower mercury varieties.

Another fresh-fish concern is the way that it’s caught or raised. In some cases, it’s smarter to pick wild; in other situations, farmed is better. Read up on our tips for choosing healthy and sustainable fish.

Bottom Line: Mix up the types you eat and stick to smaller portions of higher-mercury tuna.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Choose the Right Syrup

Don't be fooled by the label "grade A" on a bottle of maple syrup: It's no better than grade B.

Choosing the Right Meats

Grilling is one of the lightest ways to cook, but to keep it that way, pick leaner meats. Make healthy meal choices with these tips from Food Network.

Ahi Tuna Done Right

If the thought of preparing ahi tuna at home intimidates you, fear no more. Get some sushi-grade tuna and try this easy Seared Ahi Tuna With Ponzu Glaze recipe.

Food Network Apps

In the Kitchen

Get over 70,000 FN recipes on all your mobile devices.

Facebook Messenger

Ask our bot for recipes, meal ideas and daily food trivia.

Amazon Echo

Just say "Alexa, enable Food Network skill" to get started.