The Creamery Restaurant

Getting reviews...

Made with the family’s own dark syrup and a flaky lard-and-butter crust according to Kate McDonald Beattie’s original recipe, the maple cream pie at The Creamery Restaurant has not changed in nearly half a century. In fact, Beattie herself made the pies, topping slices of rich maple-sweetened custard with freshly whipped cream, until she was in her early 90s. One of her daughters is the current pie maker for the family-owned restaurant, which serves homey fare in an 1891 building that was once the local creamery.

Special Dish: Maple Cream Pie

Seen an error? Report This Listing

Related Content

Copy That!

Off the Menu

Make restaurant favorites at home with copycat recipes from FN Magazine.

On the Road with Guy

Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives

Let Guy take you on a coast-to-coast tour Friday at 9|8c.