1 / 21
Photo: Jeremiah Alley ©
Part 1: Maddened by Marshmallows
After the roll of Guy's four die, the chefs had to incorporate mayonnaise and marshmallows into their innovative appetizers for Game 1, plus utilize a food mill and shop within four minutes. Upon hearing "marshmallows," Trevor instantly thought s'mores, but on a savory route, using bacon and mixing the mayonnaise into melted chile chocolate. "You nailed everything on the innovative," says Catherine McCord, but Melissa d'Arabian points out the challenge was an appetizer not dessert. They send Trevor home for the technicality.