Penny for Your Thoughts

By: Grant Dudley
FNS7 Episode 1 Finalist Arrivals

FNS7 Episode 1 Finalist Arrivals

FNS7 Episode 1 finalists Penny Davidi chatting with finalists.

Photo by: Edward Chen / Creel Films ©2011, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Edward Chen / Creel Films, 2011, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved

Right or wrong, good or bad — she made for great television. Every interesting story needs to have an antagonist, and wouldn’t you agree Penny filled that role perfectly? Whether you like to admit it or not, I bet that she brought many of you to your TVs week after week. Every Sunday you all hoped to see her get her comeuppance. And, well, last night she finally did.

Yes, the self-proclaimed “Middle Eastern Mama” was a difficult personality, a pot stirrer and someone you loved to dislike. But, to keep engagement up, we needed a little drama — a bit of spice — and no one dished it out like Penny. Remember Debbie Lee from Season 5? She reminded me of her. I enjoyed that Penny brought some “Deb drama” back to Food Network Star. Come on, this is a reality show — drama is a good thing!

Then there was Chris. If I were to cast Chris as a character in a story, he would have been the resident class clown. I have no doubt that he’s a great, fun guy, and probably a really good cook. However, his endless bouncing off the walls wasn’t appealing to watch. I don’t mind “big kid” personalities, but know when to shut it down and act your age. I just kept thinking someone needed to give him a timeout (or a Xanax).

Wolfgang Puck is a trip. Anytime the man is on this show, I know something unexpected will happen (which I love). When he escorted Jyll with a y to the kitchen to show her how to properly make risotto, I smiled. Well, hey, he’s the master, and I think she should embrace his correction and learn from it. Was she embarrassed? Absolutely, but this is one of those times when she should simply feel honored to have a world-renowned expert show her how to better the dish. Shake it off Jyll with a y — at least you’re headed to New York. You did something right!

The remaining finalists head to the Big Apple next week. Let’s all get in a New York state of mind.

Next Up

Haters Gonna Hate Karma: Penny's Attack on Matthew Backfires

Watch what happens when Penny sabotages Matthew in the Star Challenge.

Caption It: Face Plant

Caption this photo of Food Network's Alton, Giada and Bobby on Food Network Star, then tune in Sunday at 9pm/8c to find out what's going on.

Caption It: Bunny Ears

Caption this photo of Food Network Star finalists during a silly moment on set, then tune in to a new episode on Sunday, June 30 at 9pm/8c.

Star-a-Day: Trace Barnett

Get to know Trace Barnett, a finalist competing on Food Network Star, Season 13.

Caption It: You're Invited to a Tiki Party

We're challenging you, Food Network Star fans, to write your best captions for this moment.

Giada Reveals Why Food Network Star Is So Hard and What Finalists Should Do Before They Get Here

Hear from Food Network Star mentor Giada De Laurentiis about the importance of self-confidence in this competition.