The Cutthroat Kitchen competitors are no strangers to host Alton Brown's diabolical sabotages – from ingredient swaps to alternate sources of heat, there's no limit to the amount of tricks up his sleeve. Still, no one could have prepared for Sally, a mechanical cow that had udders underneath that one chef had to milk in order to get the dairy needed to create a Tres Leches cake, which involves three types of milk.

"Here's the terrible thing. We didn't label them either," said Alton to Judge Jet Tila. "So they really had to know their dairies." Chef Shane was given this sabotage and made an ice-cream, which turned out to be a very smart move. "The cool thing about ice-cream is that it makes your mouth cold and once your mouth is cold you don't notice certain things in the rest of the food," said Alton on this week's After-Show. 'If I didn't trust the rest of my food, say my cake, I would so make you an ice-cream!" Ultimately, Chef Shane won the show and Chef Candace was eliminated, on account of her 'cake' being more like a crepe. "It just doesn't work, man," said Judge Tila.

Click the play button above to hear more from Alton and Jet, and to see Chef Shane try to milk Sally up close.