Poll: Who Went Home Too Soon?

No Star hopeful wants to make an early exit from the competition, but unfortunately, someone always has to be the first, second or third to go. Cristie Schoen, Kara Sigle and Josh Lyons — eliminated in episodes one, two and three, respectively — didn't have many opportunities to show Bob and Susie their best stuff. Their mentors only had limited time to coach them and help them improve. With more time to learn and grow, could Cristie, Kara or Josh have been a serious contender?

That leads to our poll of the week: In your opinion, which of these three early eliminations happened too soon? Let us know which eliminated finalist you'd bring back to the competition.

Who's your favorite finalist still in the running? Don’t forget to cast your Fan Vote up to 10 times per day.

Keep Reading

Next Up

POLL: Who Went Home Too Early?

Do you agree with all of the judges' elimination decisions so far? Vote in Star Talk's poll.

Poll: Who Should Go Home on Sunday?

Who, in your opinion, doesn't have the chops to be a Food Network star? Which finalist do you want to see go home next?

Poll: Most Fashionable Finalist

Of the remaining 11 finalists, who's the most fashionable?

Poll: Who's On Thin Ice?

Which of the remaining 10 Food Network Star finalists is skating on thin ice as the competition moves into its second half?

Star Poll: Pick Your Dish

If you were a tourist on the Star bus tour, which of these three winning dishes would you most want to sample?

Poll: Who Was the Best Mentor?

Cast your vote in our Food Network Star poll. Which of Food Network Star's mentors, Bobby, Alton or Giada, was the most successful this season?

Poll: Which Burger Would You Order?

If you could order up a burger from the Producers' Challenge, whose would you pick?

Poll: Did the Right Finalist Earn Salvation?

Cast your vote to tell Star Talk which eliminated Food Network Star finalist was most deserving of redemption on Star Salvation.

Fan Poll: Vote for Your Early Favorites

Cast your vote in this fan poll to tell us who your favorite Food Network Star finalist is so far.