The Secret Ingredient to the Best Boxed Mac and Cheese

Sorry, butter and milk — you’ve been replaced.

Updated on January 18, 2024

Related To:

Homemade Creamy Macaroni and Cheese Pasta in a Bowl


Boxed mac and cheese with a secret ingredient

Photo by: bhofack2/Getty Images

bhofack2/Getty Images

When I was younger, my brother and I would fight over boxed mac and cheese. He preferred his with so much butter and milk that it was basically a soup, whereas I liked mine to be as thickly sauced as possible. Sometimes, I would skip the butter and milk altogether to avoid thinning it out too much, which often resulted in clumps of powdered cheese and dry pasta. Looking back, I can’t blame him for trying to force in some extra ingredients.

Given those early experiments, it's perhaps unsurprising that, as I grew older, I found myself eating less boxed mac and cheese. A few weeks ago, however, I was running low on groceries and needed a quick and easy lunch. I grabbed a box of Annie’s Mac and Cheese (something I normally keep in the pantry for my three-year-old niece) and fired up a pot of water. While I was cooking the pasta, I noticed a tip listed on the very bottom of the box: If you want a creamier mac and cheese, try replacing the butter and milk with a few spoonfuls of Greek yogurt. I was skeptical, but since I always have some Greek yogurt on hand, I figured it couldn’t hurt to try.

Once the pasta was cooked, I stirred in the cheese powder and a few big dollops of yogurt. The finished result looked promising, but I still took my first bite with a bit of trepidation. I was blown away. The Greek yogurt created a mac and cheese that was smooth, creamy and perfectly on point — and, thanks to the yogurt’s slightly tangy flavor, the entire dish actually tasted cheesier, too! I’m not exaggerating when I say that it was some of the best mac and cheese I’ve ever had in my life, and that includes homemade and restaurant versions.

That afternoon, I sang the praises of Greek yogurt to everyone I know. I even inspired one of my coworkers to try it when she made a box for her kids, who gobbled it up with rave reviews. Now, I consider myself a reformed mac and cheese hater. I’ll definitely be keeping a box on hand — and a container of Greek yogurt to go with it!


Photo by: LauriPatterson/Getty Images

LauriPatterson/Getty Images

How to Make Boxed Mac and Cheese Taste Better

To improve the tang and overall cheesiness of your boxed mac, add 2 to 3 tablespoons of plain Greek yogurt to the cooked and drained pasta while it's still warm. Toss to combine, then stir in the cheese powder until it's uniformly blended. Whole-milk Greek yogurt is best, but low-fat or even nonfat versions will still taste great.

Related Links:

Next Up

The Secret Ingredient to the Best Glazed Meatloaf

Your meatloaf will taste meatier, richer, juicier and just flat-out more delicious thanks to this unexpected addition.

Favorite Macaroni and Cheese Recipes

Satisfy your cravings for this all-American favorite.

The Best Dips for Your Pretzels

Do the twist for these clever pairings.

These Are the Best Potatoes for Mashing

Choosing the right type of potato is the best way to make excellent mashed potatoes, every time.

The Best Bread for Making French Toast

There are a few golden rules you should follow. #1: Don’t use pre-sliced bread.

Packing a Tasty Lunch for Kids

I know a lot of kids would be happy with eating chicken fingers or mac and cheese every day, but there are other healthy and yummy options out there. Check out our favorite recipes to try.

The Secret Ingredient to Easier and Faster Chicken and Dumplings

A humble pantry igredient creates long-simmered flavor fast.

The Best Ways to Use Up Leftover Chicken

Easy skillets, pastas, salads and more await.

The Best Way to Reheat Deep-Dish Pizza

Don't even think about using the microwave.