20 Cookie Boxes To Send Ahead of Your Virtual Cookie Swap

Tis' the season to be shipping and eating!

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these links.
December 03, 2020
Related To:

Though a lot of things can be said about 2020, one of the brighter parts of this year has been just how creative people have become. From Zoom weddings and happy hours to virtual birthday parties and family game nights, there isn't much you can't do with an internet connection and a computer. That's exactly why we can't think of a better idea than moving your annual office or family cookie swap party online. Send your nearest and dearest a box full of sweet and seasonal treats this December. December 4th, so marks National Cookie Day, so now is the perfect time to place all your orders. Because honestly, after everything we've all been through this year, Santa isn't the only one who deserves a sweet treat.

$23.99

Mrs. Fields does it again with these personal-sized cookie cakes. Not only can you customize them to feature a heartfelt message in the icing colors of your choosing, if you order one between now and December 6th, you can get it for 40% off too!

Buy It
$50.00 for 4 cookie tubes

If you're looking for a stocking stuffer idea that'll really make a fun and delicious impact on Christmas morning, look no further than these brightly hued chocolate chip cookies from Baked in Color. Each bite-sized morsel is made fresh and shipped the same exact day to give whoever receives them a just-got-out-of-the-oven cookie experience. The brand also offers a festive Hanukkah Cookie Tin and an incredible (and socially distant) Santa Cookie Experience, where jolly old St. Nick himself will personally deliver some holiday treats right to your door.

Buy It

If you're already planning on sending all your nearest and dearest a Christmas card this holiday season, you'll want to order quite a few of these cookie cards from Cheryl's. Each one comes with an individually-wrapped buttercream-frosted cutout cookie and features a wide range of printed messages to add a merry and bright touch to even the busiest of December days.

Buy It

This delectable tin from Christie Cookie Co. is sure to have all your loved ones envisioning dancing sugar plums. This celebratory tin comes with 18 handcrafted cookies and features the bakery's three signature flavors — chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and white chocolate macadamia nut. Friends and family can also hold on to the cute tin as a lovely keepsake even when they run out of the cookies!

Buy It
$56.00 for 20 cookies

If rainbow cookies are usually a staple at your yearly cookie swap, these festive multicolored ones from Zola Bakes are a fun way to pay homage to that tradition. This whimsical container comes with 20 cookies — 10 that are filled with traditional raspberry jam, and 10 that are filled with chocolaty hazelnut spread.

Buy It
$36.00 for 1 dozen cookies

One of the things we love most about a cookie swap is the fact that you get to leave with a variety of different sweets at the very end of it. The same can be said about this assorted cookie box from famed Los Angeles Bakery Milk Jar Cookies. Available in whole and half dozen options, the box comes stuffed with a surprise array of the bakery's best-sellers, including its signature chocolate chip. Milk Jar also offers vegan and gluten free options, so you're sure to find something for absolutely everyone on your "nice" list.

Buy It

All your loved ones can have their dessert and decorate it too thanks to this ingenious DIY kit from Insomnia Cookies. Each one comes with 15 blank sugar and snickerdoodle "canvases," plus a fun collection of gel icing tubes, buttercream frosting and jimmies to give everyone a brand-new way to show off their holiday spirit. Go ahead and order an extra kit for yourself too — it'll give you the perfect excuse to hold a cookie decorating party over Zoom!

Buy It

This celebratory cookie box from Harry & David is filled with 22 dreamy shortbread and chocolate-covered sandwich cookies and features a yummy variety of seasonal flavors like fruitcake, gingerbread, coconut, cranberry-orange and peppermint.

Buy It

We all have that one friend who always knows the best fast-food restaurants in town. Pay tribute to all their foodie knowledge with this hilarious "fry" basket from The Cookie Joint. Each "crinkle cut" is made out of buttery shortbread cookie dough and features unique flavors like mint chocolate chip, red velvet, lemon poppyseed, cinnamon sugar, and cookies n’ creme to name a few. It also comes with an irresistible array of chocolate, marshmallow, hazelnut, salted caramel and peanut butter dipping sauces. How's that for a cup (or paper carton) of cheer?

Buy It
$27.00 for 6 cookies

These red-and-green hued black and white cookies from Dana's Bakery are sure to put their recipient in a holly jolly mood. They also offer blue and white ones for Hanukkah and a delicious collection of gingerbread-, sugar cookie- and eggnog-flavored macarons perfect for spreading even more holiday cheer.

Buy It
$55.95 for 7 cookie arrangement

It's sure to look a lot like Christmas when your friends and family pull this edible poinsettia bouquet out of its box. Not only is it made entirely out of buttery frosted cookies and can easily be used as a centerpiece on their kitchen table — they won't need to worry about watering it either!

Buy It
$13.50

Chances are you've already heard of Sprinkles' amazing cupcake offerings. Now it's time to discover their line of tender and chewy cookies. Your loved ones will get three jumbo-sized ones inside this cookie kit, plus 3 cups of vanilla cream cheese, dark chocolate buttercream and salty caramel cream cheese frosting shots to decorate to their (and Santa's) heart's desire.

Buy It
$46.00

The weather outside might be fretful, but these holiday cookies from Milk Bar are oh-so-delightful. The tin comes with 6 of the brand's fan-favorite cookies including their compost and confetti rounds, plus six of their peppermint pretzel snaps which contains crunchy notes of caramel, chocolate and white chocolate bark.

Buy It
$27.00 for 4 cookies

You just can't have a discussion about cookies without mentioning Levain Bakery. Thanks to this signature cookie assortment, your closest pals will get all four of the bakery's original cookie flavors, including Chocolate Chip Walnut, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip and Oatmeal Raisin. Now all that's left for them to do is grab the milk!

Buy It
$67.00 for 6 cookies

If you're looking to give your nearest and dearest a more luxurious cookie experience this holiday season, look no further than this Chef's Tasting box from Better Than Your Mother's. With flavors like Sweet Potato Casserole, Apple Tart Tartan, Chocolate Pecan Pie, Sea Salt Chocolate Chip and Speculoos, you'll never look at basic sugar cookies the same again! Did we mention they're also big enough to eat with a fork and knife!

Buy It
$65.00 for 1 dozen

Chocolate Peppermint Crunch, Brown Butter Cranberry Oatmeal and Caramel Chocolate Hazelnut are just some of the joyous flavors your loved ones will find inside this rustic limited-edition cookie box from Maman.

Buy It

Forget the halls, this year it's all about deck the cookie with these interactive kits from Color My Cookie! This Ho Ho Ho themed one comes with six iced shortbread reindeer-, ornament- and Santa hat-shaped cookies, plus edible watercolor food dye, edible glitter and sprinkles, so all the little elves in your life can create their very own winter wonderland.

Buy It
$74.99 for 2 boxes of 6

Your loved ones don't need to be walking in a winter wonderland to enjoy these holiday-themed cookies from NYC's very own Chip City. Each bundle contains frozen cookie dough in flavors like Red Velvet Hot Chocolate, Chocolate Peppermint Crinkle, Falalala Fetti, Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Cranberry Oat and Oatmeal Apple Pie to give your friends and family a sweet treat they can make whenever they find themselves in need of something to go along with their eggnog or mulled wine.

Buy It
$44.95 for 6 cookies

All your friend's troubles are sure to be miles away (for a little while at least) when they open up these special-edition candy cane-studded chocolate chunk cookies from beloved chocolatier Jacques Torres. They're the perfect embodiment of the phrase "merry and bright."

Buy It

Though they aren't jingle bells per se, these delectable chocolate-covered sandwich cookies from Sugar Plum Chocolates will make spirits bright just as much. This sampler box comes with nine covered cookies in yummy flavors like white chocolate with cranberry, dark chocolate with toasted coconut and milk chocolate with toffee.

Buy It

Related Links:

Next Up

No-Bake Chocolate Cookies to Ease Up the Holiday Cookie Swap

Ease up on your holiday prep (and on your oven) with simpler, no-bake cookies that'll disappear from the cookie swap just as quickly as any baked ones.

10 Recipes to Win Your Holiday Cookie Swap — Fall Fest

It's time to preheat your oven; holiday cookie season has arrived, and these treats are sweet-tooth-satisfying.

Brownie Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Food Network Kitchen's Brownie Cookies are the best of both worlds, thanks to their crunchy-chewy edges and moist, fudgy center.

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

These soft and crackly cookies are a staple in Italian bakeries, but you don't have to be an Italian baker to replicate the signature look.

Alton's Chocapocalypse Cookie — 12 Days of Cookies

Celebrate the holiday season with Alton's Chocapocalypse Cookie.

Classic Sugar Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Stick to the classics with Food Network Kitchen's traditional sugar cookies with crispy edges and a soft, buttery center.

Anne’s Meringue Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Lighter than air but full of flavor, Anne’s cinnamon-laced cookies are made with just five ingredients, including crunchy chopped almonds.

Ina’s Shortbread Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Get Ina Garten’s Shortbread Cookies recipe and check out Food Network's 12 Days of Cookies for dozens more recipes and sweet ideas.

Healthier Holiday Cookies

There are many ways to go about holiday cookie-making without gobs of butter and sugar—really, there are! Here are some ways to indulge sensibly.

Related Pages