6 Best Boxed Brownie Mixes of 2026, Tested and Reviewed
We baked over 100 brownies and blind-tasted them to find the best picks for rich chocolate flavor, chewy edges and fudgy centers.
Taylor Murray
Tested by Taylor Murray
Few baking shortcuts deliver quite like a boxed brownie mix. With a couple of eggs, some oil or butter, and water, you can have a pan ready for the oven in minutes without measuring flour or melting chocolate. Whether you're making a last-minute dessert or satisfying a weeknight chocolate craving, store-bought brownie mixes make it easy to get something sweet on the table in no time.
But an appealing picture on the box doesn't tell you much about what's inside. Some brownies have chewy edges and centers so fudgy they barely hold together, while others are firmer and more cakelike. A brownie can look deeply chocolatey but taste mostly of sugar, while another delivers intense chocolate richness that begs for a glass of milk.
To find the best boxed brownies, we baked 15 mixes, including three gluten-free options, and tasted them blind so brand recognition wouldn't influence our impressions. We looked for satisfying texture, balanced sweetness and chocolate flavor that made us want another bite, then revisited the brownies the next day to see how well they held up.
Our Top Store-Bought Brownie Mix Picks
Taylor Murray
How We Tested
To find the best store-bought brownie mixes, we prepared 15 boxed mixes, including three gluten-free options, following each brand's package instructions.
Batter Test: We prepared each mix according to the box's instructions. We used the same brand of eggs, butter and oil for each to maintain uniformity and eliminate differences. During this test, we also assessed how easily each mix came together, noting the batter's consistency and how readily it spread in the pan.
Bake Test: We baked each according to package instructions, then let them cool completely. We examined each for even baking, looking for doming, sunken centers and differences between the edges and middle. We also noted whether the top developed a shiny, crackly crust.
Taste Test: We took a bite from each brownie, making sure to assign each a letter to eliminate brand bias. We compared pieces from the edges and centers, evaluating chewiness, tenderness, moisture and whether the texture leaned fudgy or cakey. For flavor, we considered chocolate intensity, sweetness and any bitter or artificial tastes.
Next-Day Test: We revisited the brownies the following day to assess changes in flavor and texture, including whether they had begun to dry out or become stale.
What's the Difference Between Glass and Metal Baking Pans?
You’ll want to read this before making your next batch of brownies.
- Rich, lingering chocolate flavor
- Balanced sweetness
- Moist crumb
- Crunchy chocolate chunks
- Less edge chew than some other mixes
- Uneven, somewhat crumbly top
The Trader Joe's Brownie Truffle Baking Mix delivered the kind of intense chocolate flavor we'd expect from a chocolate truffle, with enough sweetness to balance the bitter cocoa notes. The flavor lingered after each bite, and the chocolate chunks added a slight crunch once the brownies had cooled. The crumb was moist without being greasy, with slightly chewy edges surrounding a tender interior. Its mottled, rippled top wasn't the smoothest in the lineup, and other mixes delivered more chew, but its rich chocolate flavor and satisfying texture made it our best overall pick.
- What's Needed 1/2 cup melted butter, 2 eggs
- Flavor Chocolate truffle
- Size 16 ounces
Taylor Murray
- Intense, rich chocolate flavor
- Chocolate chunks throughout
- Soft, moist interior
- Top crust adds satisfying texture contrast
- Less chewy than some other mixes
Betty Crocker's Supreme Chocolate Chunk mix delivered an intensely chocolatey brownie, with chocolate chunks throughout that made each bite feel especially rich. The interior was soft and moist, while the crust added a pleasing contrast that kept the texture interesting. It wasn't particularly chewy and didn't stick to our teeth, making it a strong choice for anyone who prefers a tender brownie with plenty of chocolate.
- What's Needed 1/4 cup water, 1/3 cup vegetable oil, 1 egg
- Flavor Double chocolate
- Size 18 ounces
Taylor Murray
- Pronounced crackly crust with a slight crunch
- Very tender, moist interior without greasiness
- Chocolate chunks throughout
- Slightly too sweet
- Little chew
- Shorter chocolate finish than some other picks
Ghirardelli has established itself as one of the best chocolate companies in the world, and its baking mix lives up to the reputation. The Dark Chocolate Brownie Mix produced brownies with a deep brown interior studded with chocolate chunks and a pronounced crackly top. That crust had a slight crunch, giving way to a very tender center that was moist without being greasy. The flavor reminded us of brownie-batter ice cream: sweet, chocolatey and distinctly reminiscent of a homemade brownie in an appealing, nostalgic way. It was slightly too sweet for our tester's taste, and the chocolate flavor didn't linger as long as Trader Joe's, but the contrast between the crisp surface and soft interior was especially satisfying.
- What's Needed 1/4 cup water, 1/2 cup vegetable oil, 1 egg
- Flavor Dark chocolate
- Size 20 ounces
Taylor Murray
- Rich chocolate flavor with balanced sweetness
- Chewy edges and meltingly soft center
- Stayed moist and flavorful the next day
- Slight graininess
- Delicate center was difficult to pick up
- Touch oily
Even among the conventional mixes, King Arthur's Gluten-Free Fudge Brownie Mix stood out as a brownie we wanted to keep coming back to. The chocolate was rich without bitterness, with a moderate sweetness that kept it from tasting cloying. Firm, chewy edges surrounded a fudgy center so delicate it barely held together when picked up. We noticed slight graininess and a touch of oiliness, but the melt-in-your-mouth texture more than compensated. It remained just as enjoyable the next day, with no noticeable drying or staleness.
- What's Needed 1/2 cup melted butter, 2 tablespoons water, 2 eggs
- Flavor Chocolate fudge
- Size 17 ounces
Taylor Murray
- Thick, sturdy brownies
- Perfect for decorating
- Dense, chewy edges
- Center was less tender than other picks
- Can dry out a few days after baking
The Krusteaz Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Brownie Mix produced thick brownies that held their shape with a firm, cakelike center and dense, chewy edges. A thin crust broke delicately when we cut into the batch, revealing chocolate chunks inside. The flavor was sweet but balanced by chocolate richness, without any bitter or artificial notes. Though the center wasn't as tender as some other picks, the brownies were satisfying on their own and neither dry nor greasy. After a few days of storage, these brownies did get a little drier than others. The Krusteaz mix would be a top choice for anyone wanting a good base for frosted or decorated brownies.
- What's Needed 1/3 cup water, 1/2 cup vegetable oil, 1 egg
- Flavor Double chocolate
- Size 20 ounces
Taylor Murray
- Thick, sturdy squares that held together well
- Crackly crust contrasts with soft interior
- Moist without being greasy
- Firmer edges add chew
- Center sank slightly
- Less meltingly soft than some other picks
A brownie destined for a sundae needs enough structure to support a scoop of ice cream, and the Bob's Red Mill Fudgy Brownie Mix produced thick squares that held together well. The sugary, crackly crust contrasted nicely with the soft interior, while the firmer edges added a little chew. It was neither greasy nor dry, and the chocolate aroma had a subtle coffeelike quality. The center sank slightly during baking, but overall, this was a satisfying, well-rounded brownie whose sturdy texture made it our pick for piling on ice cream and sauce.
- What's Needed 1/2 cup melted butter or oil, 2 eggs, 1 tablespoon water
- Flavor Profile Chocolate fudge
- Size 14 ounces
Taylor Murray
Tips and Tricks for Elevating Boxed Brownie Mixes
Batter Inclusions: Fold in chocolate chunks or white chocolate chips for pockets of sweetness, or chopped walnuts or pecans for crunch. To make a peanut butter swirl, drip small spoonfuls over the batter and gently drag a knife through them before baking. Vanilla or peppermint extract can also change the flavor, but start with just a little to not overwhelm the other flavors.
Ingredient Swaps: An easy way to upgrade a boxed mix is to replace oil with an equal amount of melted butter. This will give the brownie a richer, more buttery flavor, though the brownies will be slightly firmer once cooled. Milk can replace water for added richness, and an extra egg yolk can take that even further. Try one change at a time so you can see how it affects your chosen mix.
Baking Tips: Use a pan size recommended on the box, since a larger pan produces thinner brownies that bake more quickly. For fudgy results, begin checking at the earliest listed baking time and look for a toothpick inserted into the center to have moist crumbs rather than wet batter. Let the brownies cool completely before cutting, so the center has time to set. A parchment sling makes lifting them out easier, and wiping the knife between cuts helps keep edges neat.
Topping Ideas: Sprinkle chocolate chips, chopped nuts or crushed freeze-dried fruit over the batter before baking. A sprinkle of flaky sea salt elevates any brownie with texture and a subtle contrast to the sweet flavors. Try a drizzle of chocolate fudge or caramel sauce for a bakery-level touch. Keep the toppings light enough that the brownie can remain the star of the show.
Taylor Murray
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes brownies fudgy instead of cakey?
Fudgy brownies generally have a higher proportion of fat to flour, while cakey brownies have more structure and lift. With a boxed brownie mix, follow the instructions for fudgy brownies if the package offers multiple options. Adding an extra whole egg can create a firmer, more cakelike structure. Don’t overbake, as this can dry out the center of a pan of brownies.
Should you use butter instead of oil in a brownie mix?
It depends on your preferences. Melted butter adds buttery flavor, while oil generally produces brownies that stay softer once cooled. Many mixes allow either, but check the package for specific amounts and substitution instructions.
How do you know when brownies are done baking?
Look for set edges and a center that no longer appears wet. A toothpick inserted near the center should come out with moist crumbs rather than liquid batter, though melted chocolate chips can make this harder to judge. Start checking at the earliest listed baking time and remember that brownies will firm up as they cool.
Are gluten-free brownie mixes as good as regular brownie mixes?
They certainly can be. During our blind tasting, King Arthur's Gluten-Free Fudge Brownie Mix was one of the samples we found ourselves craving long after taste-testing ended. On the other hand, the Simple Mills Brownie Mix made with almond flour had a strange, harsh taste that way overpowered any chocolate flavor. Results vary by mix, just as they do with wheat flour–based mixes.
How long do boxed brownies stay fresh?
Plain brownies generally keep well for three to four days in an airtight container at room temperature, though texture varies by mix. Let them cool completely before storing and keep them uncut when possible, to limit exposed edges. For longer storage, wrap individual portions tightly and freeze. Brownies with perishable frostings or toppings may need refrigeration.
What's the difference between dark chocolate and fudge brownie mixes?
Dark chocolate generally describes the flavor, while fudge suggests a dense, moist texture. A dark chocolate mix may have a more pronounced cocoa flavor or include bittersweet chocolate chips, but it won't necessarily taste less sweet. These descriptions aren't standardized, and a brownie can be both dark chocolate and fudgy.
Taylor Murray
Other Boxed Brownie Mixes We Tested
The Duncan Hines Chewy Fudge Brownie Mix baked with an attractive, uniform top, but tasted dry, with molasses and caramelized sugar notes overshadowing the chocolate.
The Simple Mills Gluten-Free Brownie Almond-Flour Mix had a dense, fudgy texture, but an unpleasant, nutlike bitterness that totally overwhelmed any chocolate flavor.
Finally, the Pillsbury Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix produced a flaky top and very tender interior, though its predominantly sweet flavor lacked the chocolate intensity of our favorites.
Brownie Recipes to Satisfy Every Chocolate Craving 36 Photos
Whether you're team cakey or team fudgy, we've got all the recipes you could ever need. With these great ideas, your next batch is never far away.
Why You Should Trust Our Tester
Taylor Murray is a graduate of Johnson and Wales University with a degree in Culinary Nutrition. She worked as a professional chef for over 10 years before moving into recipe and product testing and development. She has tested several hundred products for Food Network and other brands over the past six years, covering everything from carbon steel pans to food dehydrators.
Why You Should Trust Food Network Shopping Experts
Food Network Shopping Experts believe the best method for testing products is based on how our fans are going to use them in the real world. In each of our Tested and Reviewed stories, products are tested in real home kitchens that reflect real-world use cases. Our testers follow rigorous testing rubrics designed by our expert editors and take copious notes during the testing process. When choosing the best products, our testers evaluate all of the testing data and take into consideration many factors, including ease of use, price, product availability and practicality. The products covered on FoodNetwork.com are chosen completely independently by our editors without any outside influence. Our editors do not accept products in exchange for a positive review or promised coverage.