Recipe courtesy of Square Peg

Cheesesteak Pot Pie

Save Recipe
  • Level: Easy
  • Total: 1 hr
  • Active: 30 min
  • Yield: 6 servings
Share This Recipe


Cheesesteak Filling: 

4 ounces onions, small dice

3 ounces green bell peppers, medium dice

3 ounces red bell peppers, medium dice

6 tablespoons oil

2 pounds button mushrooms, quartered

2 pounds rib-eye steak, very thinly sliced

1 teaspoon salt

Cheesesteak 'Sauce':

1 cup milk

1/4 cup heavy cream

6 ounces soft American cheese, such as Velveeta

3 ounces American cheese

6 baked puff pastry rounds, for serving


  1. For the cheesesteak filling: Saute the onions and peppers in the oil until translucent, and then remove from the pan. Add the mushrooms to the pan and cook until well browned. Return the peppers and onions to the pan along with the beef. Cook the beef, chopping up with a wooden spoon, until just cooked through. Season with salt, remove from the heat and spread out on a baking sheet to chill. 
  2. For the cheesesteak sauce: Combine the milk and cream and bring to a simmer. Whisk in the cheeses until thoroughly melted and well mixed. Set aside until ready to use. 
  3. For serving: For each serving, heat 8 ounces of the steak and vegetable mixture in a saute pan. Add 4 to 5 ounces of the sauce and bring to a simmer. Cook until heated through very well and the sauce has started to reduce. Once hot, pour into bowls and top with the rounds of baked puff pastry.
Easy Turkey Pot Pie
9m Easy 98%
Sunny's Brooklyn Beef Patties
37m Intermediate 99%
Chicken Pot Pie with a Tater Tot Crust
18m Easy 100%
All-Crust Sheet Pan Chicken Pot Pie
41m Easy 98%