How To Get An Instagram-Worthy Cheese Pull

Things are about to get really cheesy!

Photo by: Photograph by Ralph Smith

Photograph by Ralph Smith

There’s something magical about warm, gooey cheese being stretched to seemingly impossible lengths — which is why you’ll find more than 60,000 #cheesepull posts on Instagram. Food Network Magazine set out to learn just how to make — and share — the perfect grilled cheese sandwich. Here's how to get an outstanding shot.

Picture-Perfect Grilled Cheese Recipe: Heat 1 tablespoon salted butter in a cast-iron or nonstick skillet over medium-low heat. Place 2 slices American cheese between 2 slices country white bread. Press the sandwich slightly, then add to the pan and cook until golden, 3 to 5 minutes per side, adding more butter when you flip, if needed.

Choose Your Cheese Wisely: American cheese is a great melter, which is why it makes the best grilled cheese, but for an extra-stretchy look, try mozzarella slices. Avoid cheeses that don’t melt, like feta, halloumi, Cotija and goat cheese.

Go Easy On Other Ingredients: If you want your shot to be all about the cheese pull, play it straight; sauce and other extras will stick to the cheese strands and steal the show.

Turn Down the Heat: Cheese melts best over low to medium heat. If the heat is too high, the fat can start separating out of the cheese, resulting in a greasy look.

Time Your Pull Just Right: Let your sandwich sit for a few seconds after cooking before you slice and pull — if the cheese is too hot, it will be hard to control. But don’t wait too long! Once the cheese cools, it can break.

Beware the Reheat: Unfortunately, cheese that sets will never look freshly melted again even if you reheat it. If you missed the shot, eat the sandwich and try again!

Photograph by Ralph Smith

Related Content:

Next Up

Get Custom Cheese Slices

Hot Tips for cooking with cheese from Food Network Kitchens' Katherine Alford: Instead of buying presliced cheese in packages, hit the deli counter to find more interesting cheeses.

6 Ways to One-Up Side Dish Favorites with Cheese — Sensational Sides

Cheesy does it, cheese lovers. Instead of taking your favorite food by the block, use cheese to improve your favorite go-to side dishes.

But I Just Want Some Pizza!?!

Pizza is many folks' an on-the-go lunch or dinner choice and a staple at kids' birthday parties. I’m not one to resist a tempting slice (it’s my favorite food, second to chocolate), but I can enjoy one without overindulging -- here’s how.

50 Grilled Cheese

Make a sandwich from Food Network Magazine for any meal of the day—even dessert!

Meet the Macaroni and Cheese Made with 10 (Yes, Really) Cheeses

Believe it or not, Sunny's decadent recipe is both simple to make and easy on the wallet.

These Cheese and Cracker Holiday Appetizers Are Anything but Basic

Warning: This post is about to get very cheesy.

Favorite Macaroni and Cheese Recipes

Satisfy your cravings for this all-American favorite.

Mix and Match Queso

Make the ultimate cheese dip with this customizable recipe.

Check Out Our

Get a sneak-peek of the new Food Network recipe page and give us your feedback.

See it Now!