(Real) Judge Empathy

By: Brandy Shearer

In every good competition show, there are always key attention-grabbing moments that make you think, “Wow. How awful/awesome/cool that must be for him/her.”  In watching the Star premiere, I actually had this reaction to quite a few things, but one in particular surprised me. As I watched the Selection Committee tell Alexis why things just weren’t working … and explain to the other hanging-by-a-thread finalists why their outlook was not so good, either … I felt about as bad for the judges as I did for the competitors. Weird, right? But then it occurred to me: Despite the fact that the judges (obviously) know it’s a contest and are well aware there can be only one winner, they still have real hope for ALL of these guys. They spend lots of time around them off-camera and, you have to figure, they probably glimpse lots of potential that we never get to see. Check out what Bob says here about DAS, Doreen and Alexis:

Susie's Extra: Ep. 1 03:07

Susie Fogelson gives some of her early impressions of the competitors.

And then to hear Susie describe her real-time reaction to Wolfgang's comments for Alexis had me totally tearing up ... Is this as heartbreaking for anyone else?? Or am I just overtired? (Entirely possible...)

Keep Reading

Next Up

A Heaping Helping of "It’s Getting Real" — Justin's Rebel Recap

Read Justin Warner's recap of Episode 9 of Food Network Star.

Caption It: Premiere Giggles at the Judges' Table

We're challenging you, Food Network Star fans, to caption this moment from the Comeback Kitchen premiere.

WATCH: What Were the Judges Thinking? The Network Speaks Out

Hear from Food Network's Bob Tuschman and Susie Fogelson in an exclusive video as they dish on their first reactions to this year's finalists.

Chatting with Guest Judges Jemele Hill and Jaymee Sire

Hear from Jemele Hill and Jaymee Sire about their upcoming appearance on Food Network Star, Season 13.