People enjoyed the buttery and slightly crispy texture of the cookies, which were perfect for decorating. The dough was easy to work with and often rolled out well after chilling. Many praised the recipe for its balance between being sweet and not overly sugary.
Common substitutions included adding vanilla extract or almond extract to enhance flavor, using powdered sugar instead of flour to prevent sticking, and experimenting with gluten-free flour. Some people also adjusted the milk or butter content depending on their altitude.
The recipe was popular for holiday events such as Christmas and Valentine's Day, often used in cookie decorating traditions with icing or sprinkles.