10 Sweetest Day Gifts Under $25 that Show Just How Much You Care

If you're not celebrating this holiday, you definitely should be!

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these links.
October 15, 2019
Related To:

If you haven't heard of Sweetest Day — which falls on October 19 this year — let us explain. Occuring on the third Saturday of October, this day is an opportunity to show your loved ones (think: sweethearts, friends and family) how much you care, usually with a small gift or sweet gesture. The day is said to have started in Cleveland in the 1920s, and is still predominately celebrated in the Midwest and Northeast. However, we think an excuse to give (and get!) a sweet gift should be celebrated everywhere. We found 10 gifts all under $25 that make it easy to show all your loved ones just how much they mean to you.

Milk Bar, $25

Sure, these are called the B'Day truffles, but that doesn't mean the poppable mini cakes should be reserved for just one day a year. Whether Sweetest Day is a holiday you're celebrating with your best friend or significant other, it's certainly an excuse to indulge in Milk Bar's iconic treat.

Buy It

Cheryl's Cookies and Brownies, $5.99

Tell your loved one exactly how you feel with Cheryl's iconic cookie cards. A gift under the $10 price point means you can send one to everyone on your list this year.

Buy It
$14

Etsy, $14

If you're in the market for something truly unique, opt for this chocolate controller for the gamer in your life. Made to order, you have the option of white, dark and milk chocolate — plus, you can add a custom engraving to personalize it.

Buy It

Stick With Me Sweets, $25

Trust us when we say this isn't your average box of chocolates. The intricately decorated bon bons come in a beautiful box designed to look like a small book. But the outside decorations are only part of it — your friend or loved one will be thoroughly impressed with how decadent the treats are. And, if you're lucky, they might even share some with you!

Buy It

Anthropologie, $14

If your bestie is a coffee lover, spice up their morning Joe with a monogrammed mug decorated with Rifle Paper Co.'s signature patterns.

Buy It
$8.50

Sugarfina, $8.50

Toast to your friends or significant other this Sweetest Day with gummy bears made with Dom Pérignon Vintage Champagne. They're the ultimate party candy, and the sweetest way to tell someone how much you love them.

Buy It
$8.48

Amazon, $8.48

Take date night to a whole new level by sprucing up homemade pizza with chili-pepper-infused honey. Mike's Hot Honey is a great addition to wings, tea, cheese or cocktails — and it's the perfect little gift for someone extra sweet this Sweetest Day.

Buy It

UncommonGoods, $16

Add a touch of personalization to your Sweetest Day gift this year with the skyline of your loved one's hometown or favorite city. The intricate map includes sporatic street names and coordinates, making wherever you're drinking feel like home.

Buy It
$8.47

Amazon, $8.47

Make sure your friends or significant other don't lose their precious (and easily misplaced) AirPods with a case that shows off their love for food. If bubble tea isn't their jam, there are plenty of other food-inspired cases including popcorn, burgers and avocados.

Buy It
$19.50

Sugarwish, $19.50

Have you ever craved candy and wished you could snap your fingers and it would be there? Well, with Sugarwish's deliverable boxes, you can almost give your friends and loved ones that experience. Pick from an assortment of sour, gummy and hard candy or let Sugarwish surprise you!

Buy It

Related Links:

Next Up

The Pioneer Woman's Instant Pot Design Is a Fan-Favorite

Plus, this Instant Pot Lux is currently on sale!

20 Awesome Host Gift Ideas for Under $25

Send your favorite holiday organizer something special this year.

25 Special Gifts for Every Food-Loving Mom You Know

We found perfect presents for mom for $50 or less.

The Best Presidents Day Sales We'll Be Shopping This Holiday Weekend

We've rounded up the best kitchenware sales for Presidents Day this year.

25+ Food Gifts That Make Shopping for the Men in Your Life Beyond Easy

Your guide to shopping for the guy who's impossible to buy for!

12 Father's Day Gifts Under $50

These budget-friendly buys don't break the bank, but still show Dad how much you care.

10+ Stocking Stuffers Under $10 Everyone Will Love

These little gifts will be the star of any holiday celebration.

10+ Thoughtful Teacher Gifts That Really Show Your Appreciation

Your favorite foodie teacher will give these gifts an A+!

10 Mother's Day Gift Baskets to Send Your Mom Some Love

Load her up on sweets and snacks for Mother's Day this year.

On TV