20 Delicious Pies You Can Ship for the Holidays

It's dessert and a care package all in one!

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.
Updated on December 11, 2023

Photo by: Photo courtesy of Goldbelly/Piedaho

Photo courtesy of Goldbelly/Piedaho

There really isn’t anything better than digging into an extra-large slice of pie at the end of a holiday dinner. However, putting one together from scratch can feel like a huge undertaking. Thankfully, if you're just not up for making a pie this year, or want to send a treat to your nearest and dearest, there's no reason why you still can't enjoy a slice of the delicious dessert. We found 20 bakeries from across the United States that offer a yummy assortment of nut-, fruit- and custard-based pies for nationwide shipping, so absolutely everyone from grandma and grandpa to mom and dad can indulge. Just be sure to order one for yourself too, especially if you happen to be staying home for the holiday!

California

$79.95

This irresistible chocolate pecan pie from Sweetie's is pretty legendary. Combining the signature gooeyness of a traditional pecan pie with the decadence of a homemade bittersweet chocolate ganache, this pie is sure to be a hit — even with people who don't usually like nuts! This pie can also be stored in the freezer for up to 3 weeks, in case whoever you send it to wants to save any leftovers for some future midnight snacking.

$89.95 for 24

If you've ever brought a pumpkin pie over to your family's feast, only to watch as everyone passes on it later because they're too stuffed from all the turkey, cornbread, stuffing and other sides they've eaten, we totally understand your frustration. Thankfully, The Pie Hole is here to offer a yummy alternative with these perfectly poppable treats. Each bite-sized round contains a velvety pumpkin puree filling and features a crispy butter crust that's also studded with pieces of crystallized ginger. A generous dollop of icing and some festive Thanksgiving sprinkles finish them off, giving you and yours a fun way to enjoy dessert without going overboard.

Believe it or not, this creamy, dreamy frozen pie from Cold Stone Creamery features a delectable sweet cream ice cream filling, ribbons of chocolaty fudge and syrupy caramel and bits of toasted pecans. It's everything you need to have the best Thanksgiving ever!

Florida

$75.95

Miami natives know that when it comes to key lime pie, Derek Kaplan's are total fire. The former firefighter has made a name for himself thanks largely to his crumbly graham cracker crusts and refreshing custardy fillings. If your family is one that prefers to deviate from “traditional” Thanksgiving desserts, this pie's the one for them.

Georgia

If your family isn't familiar with buttermilk pie, Southern Baked Pie Company can do the honors and introduce them to it. Inspired by her mother-in-law's heirloom recipe, owner Amanda Wilbanks credits this best-selling dessert as the thing that kick started her business. That's probably why the bakery was originally called "Buttermilk Pie Company" when it was founded back in 2012. Made from a light and airy combination of vanilla, nutmeg, flour, eggs, and of course, buttermilk, the custard-based pie is a delicious way for you and yours to experience something new together after spending the last few months apart.

Idaho

$69.95

Need some extra convincing on why you should order this award-winning pie from Piedaho? Oprah Winfrey can help! Not only did the bakery's breathtaking fruit pies appear on her "List of Favorite Things'' in 2019, Oprah also labeled them as "swoon worthy." Your family and friends are sure to think so too, once they lay their own eyes on one. Though the family-owned bakery offers dozens of different flavor and design combinations, this brand-new Mixed Berry Ginger pie gets our vote as the one that'll make the most impact on your Thanksgiving table, since it has both tart and spicy notes and contains a fruity mix of blueberries, raspberries and strawberries.

Illinois

$84.95

Though French fries aren't typically found sitting on a Thanksgiving table, this magical pie from Stephanie Izard's Sugargoat proves that they deserve to be there. The decadent pie features a silky malt-chocolate filling and a crunchy crust that's made entirely out of a heavenly French fry crumble (yes, you read that correctly). If your family is full of adventurous eaters, sweet and salty snack lovers or individuals who just enjoy fast food, this one-of-a-kind treat is for them.

Indiana

$39.95

This peanut butter pie might not seem like the most autumnal dessert at first, but its nutty flavor is so rich and comforting that it might just replace pecan pie as your family's new favorite Thanksgiving sweet. Billed as a cross between a freshly baked peanut butter cookie and a piece of chewy peanut butter fudge, this delectable pie can also be served cold with a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream or warm with a hot drizzle of chocolate sauce, so each one of your family members can personalize it to their own liking.

Maryland

$65.95

If you missed all those big family breakfasts and brunches as much as we did this past year, this quirky offering from Dangerously Delicious Pies is sure to have you and your loved ones feeling super nostalgic. This top seller — which is also a personal favorite of Food Network star Duff Goldman — tastes just like a fruity stack of blueberry pancakes and can even be topped with maple syrup for a fun dessert that can also double as breakfast the very next day.

Michigan

$79.95

This indulgent chocolate cream pie from Achatz Handmade Pie Co. was made for all those chocolate-lovers in your family or friend group. Whether you're sending it for Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving, absolutely everyone will be giving thanks for this decadent dessert. It's made from luxurious chocolate pastry cream, creamy whipped topping and luscious shaved chocolate curls.

Minnesota

$59.95

When it comes to can't-miss sweets, Betty's Pies is a must-try! Not only has the bakery been selling pies since 1956, but people travel all across the world to try their fun flavors. Luckily, you can send one directly to your family this Thanksgiving and save them money on airfare and gas. Though Betty's 5 Layer Chocolate Cream Pie is their most popular, this best-selling Coconut Cream pie is a close-second. Our favorite part is toasted coconut topping, which adds just enough crunch to beautifully offset the fluffiness of the pie's creamy filling.

New York

$99.95

"This is pretty much the greatest thing that has happened to me, besides the birth of my children." That's what TV personality Kelly Ripa had to say after eating this over-the-top creation from Food Network's very own Zac Young. We have a sneaking suspicion you'll feel similarly about this hybrid treat. Featuring a pecan pie on the button, a pumpkin pie in the middle and an apple spice cake on top, this PieCaken is truly life-changing!

$84.95

Ask any foodie and they'll tell you last year was all about hot honey. This year, we're going to be so bold and say it's time for salted honey to shine. That's the main ingredient behind this cult-favorite custard pie from Four & Twenty Blackbirds. Though this delicious pie is the complete package, something tells us it's the flaked Maldon sea salt topping that'll turn your nearest and dearest into total salted honey stans.

$74.95

Pies 'n' Thighs is practically a Brooklyn landmark; thankfully, your loved ones don't need to actually be in NY state in order to enjoy a slice of the eatery's signature sour cherry and pear crumble pie. Loaded up with refreshing pops of tart cherries, cubed pears, fresh ginger, zesty lemon and crunchy brown sugar, it's a great replacement for that ultra-basic Thanksgiving fruit salad. Food Network's Guy Feiri is also a huge fan, so you can rest assured that it's absolutely delicious — or as Guy would say, it's money, gangsta and out of bounds!

Texas

$74.95

You know that saying that goes, "Everything is bigger in Texas?" You can totally apply that same sentiment to this delicious pecan pie from Goode Co. Barbeque, which is "gooier and richer than any other" nut pie out there. It's made from actual pecans that have been harvested directly from the banks of the Brazos River and comes in a super elegant wooden gift box that can be reused as a keepsake after the pie is eaten.

Wisconsin

$69.95

When it comes to tried and true Thanksgiving desserts, apple pie is always a winner. Dubbed by Milwaukee Magazine as the "best apple pie in America," this caramel-drizzled one from The Elegant Farmer is as mesmerizing to look at as it is to eat! The pie is baked inside a brown paper bag, which results in a unique top crust that's crunchy in texture and a beautiful bottom crust that's perfectly flaky. The crust also tastes like a sugar cookie, so all your little cousins, nieces and nephews will still enjoy it even if they're picky about fruit!

Multiple Locations

Mascarpone and tart cranberries aren't a combination we'd thought we'd ever need in our lives, but after laying our eyes on this tri-colored pie from Sweet Things Bakeshop, we stand deliciously corrected. You'll find both ingredients inside the filling of this unique dessert, plus a crispy chocolate cookie-crumb crust that tastes a lot like America's favorite sandwich cookie…you know the one!

Harry & David's is known nationwide for their beautiful array of thoughtful and delicious gift offerings, and this towering pumpkin pie is no exception. Made with real pumpkin and traditional warming spices like nutmeg, cinnamon and ginger, this deep-dish pie is truly the be-all-and-end-all of pumpkin desserts. We have a feeling your family will love the whipped cream topping, which is hand-pipped and dusted with an adequate amount of pumpkin pie spice.

If your family is full of cookie-loving kiddos (and adults), this crispy, crunchy Chocolate Chip Pie from Tate's Bake Shop is sure to put the "happy" in everyone's Thanksgiving. A delicious hybrid between the brand's signature thin chocolate chip cookies and their super fudgey walnut brownies, this Chocolate Chip Pie is studded with ample chocolate chips and housed in a buttery shortbread crust to create a melt-in-your-mouth dessert that can be eaten heated up or sliced up and dunked directly into a glass of milk.

Is there anything Milk Bar can't do?! We find ourselves asking that question every holiday season, and the answer is always a joyous "no." Chances are you've got quite a few Milk Bar fans in your family, so spoil them this Turkey Day by sending one of these sinfully delicious limited-edition pies their way. The hybrid dessert combines the bakery's signature namesake butterscotch pie with the spicy flavor of pumpkin pie, resulting in the ultimate ooey gooey fall treat.

Related Content:

Next Up

All the Ingredient Substitutions You Need for Thanksgiving

If something goes missing or a guest arrives with a last-minute request, don't panic. Here's how to substitute nearly every traditional Thanksgiving ingredient.

Giada's Thanksgiving Wine Picks

Giada pairs her Thanksgiving menu with fantastic wines.

What to Drink with Bobby's Menu

Round out Bobby Flay's Thanksgiving menu with Food Network's wine pairing guide to see what to drink with his spicy, feisty meal.

QUIZ: What's Your Thanksgiving Cocktail?

Find out what libation to serve with your feast.

Melissa's Top 8 Money-Saving Tips for Thanksgiving

From shopping for a turkey to buying pies, Melissa d'Arabian, the host of Food Network's Ten Dollar Dinners, shares her top tips to save money this Thanksgiving.

Thanksgiving Planning Guide

Simple tips for planning your Thanksgiving dinner.

QUIZ: Which Pumpkin Pie Should You Make for Thanksgiving?

Find out which pie you should serve at your Thanksgiving feast.

Oprah's Favorite Hot Cocoa Bomb Is the Perfect Holiday Gift

Everyone from your coworkers to kids will love this festive snowman-shaped hot chocolate bomb.

Oprah's Favorite Things 2023 Is Here — and It Has 30+ Food Gifts

Our editors combed through Oprah's extensive list of favorite things to find the very best gifts of the year.