Is Fancy Tinned Fish Healthier for You Just Because It’s More Expensive?

Here's why you shouldn't judge a can of fish by its packaging, no matter how pretty it is.

Follow Laura on:

Related To:

Photo by: Fcafotodigital/Getty Images

Fcafotodigital/Getty Images

You’ve seen them — the gorgeous, eye-catching, elaborately-decorated tins of fish that make you want to buy one in every color. Once reserved for fancy markets, this gussied-up version of tinned fish has taken over grocery store shelves in recent years, too. But are they actually any better for you than old-school, no-frills brands like Chicken of the Sea, Starkist or Bumblebee? Brands like Fishwife certainly look stunning on a grazing board and serve as a quick, easy hostess gift with a bottle of wine, and there are some key differences that set the brand apart from the more mass-produced cans that have been commonplace in American supermarkets for decades. We know better than to judge a can of fish by its packaging, so we did some digging and talked to the experts to find out if fancy tinned fish is actually better for you than the standard. As it turns out, there are a few different factors you should look at when determining quality. "When you're comparing cans, look at the species, the ingredient list and how the brand handles mercury," says Lauren Manaker, MS, RDN, LD. "Those details tell you more than packaging that just looks upscale," she adds. Here are some other things to keep in mind while shopping.

Nutritional Benefit

Canned fish is a great source of protein, no matter what brand you go with. "Tinned fish packs a lot of nutrition into a small, shelf-stable can," Manaker shares. "Fatty fish like salmon, sardines, mackerel and albacore are good sources of the omega-3s EPA and DHA," she adds further. Manakin says that these fats are linked to heart health and play a role in brain and eye function; tinned fish can also include vitamin D, vitamin B12 and selenium. So, it’s safe to say that if you’re consuming tinned fish, you’re getting a great source of nutrients no matter what version you go with. However, the preparation of the fish has a huge impact on the nutritional value, Manaker cautions. She notes that many premium canned fish brands pack the fish raw and cook it once in the can. Alternatively, many mass-produced brands are cooked twice, and she notes that a second cook can reduce the natural oils and nutrients. Furthermore, Manaker adds that some premium brands pack whole fillets with fewer added ingredients and often share more specific sourcing information.

Check the Source

Transparency in sourcing is a great way to understand the quality of the tinned fish you’re buying. A simpler supply chain means it’s easier to trace where your fish comes from, which generally results in better quality. If you know where your fish came from, it’s easier to trace and eradicate food safety issues if and when they arise. In the case of Fishwife, the brand relies on small-batch fisheries that are Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) and Aquaculture Stewardship Council (Council - ASC) certified. Better yet, the website lists exactly where each of their products is sourced from and where it is packaged.

Manaker notes that seeing the phrase "small-batch" on a label doesn’t necessarily guarantee a more nutritious product. "It's the sourcing practices and transparency behind the label that count," she stresses. "Many of the world's fish stocks face real pressure from overfishing," she explains, adding, "Some fishing methods also catch a lot of unintended marine life, known as bycatch. Choosing responsibly sourced fish helps support fisheries that are managed to stay healthy over time."

However, it’s not just the artisanal brands of tinned fish that are traceable. Italian brand Cento, Bumblebee and Chicken of the Sea all have codes printed on the can that you can type in on the website to discover the fishing vessel, catch area and catch method used to source your tuna.

Mercury Levels

Manaker says it’s important to check how each brand handles mercury levels, since federal regulations do not require tinned fish brands to individually test every fish or batch for mercury levels. "Bigger, longer-lived fish like albacore usually carry more mercury than smaller fish like skipjack or sardines," she says. Safe Catch publishes clear information about their mercury testing directly on the website and is one of the only brands that tests every single tuna they sell. Alternatively, Fishwife does not include clear guidance on their mercury testing policy anywhere on the website.

The Bottom Line: Overall, eye-catching packaging doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re getting a better product, so it’s always best to do your own due diligence when shopping. The standard brands that you’ve seen on supermarket shelves for years still contain nutritional value and offer a quick and easy way to trace where your fish came from. However, there’s a good chance that the artisanal brands of tinned fish are made from smaller batches, contain whole fillets with less additives and have a shorter supply chain. The key differences come down to how each brand handles mercury testing, how the fish is packaged and if any additives are included.

Related Content:

Next Up

Fish Sticks: A Healthier Catch

Although fish sticks can be a great way to introduce kids to seafood, they're basically fried finger food. Instead of raiding the freezer, whip up this version.

You Won’t Believe What This Tinned “Fish” is Made Of

Company Seed to Surf is aiming to make a truly plant-based fish.

Homemade Cake Pops Are an Easy Just-Because Gift

Dan Langan’s bite-size dessert will wow your friends. Trust us.

How to Shop for Groceries When Everything Is More Expensive

With a few thoughtful strategies (and a trip down the frozen aisle) you can stretch your grocery budget even when things are tight.

Are Plant-Based Meat and Fish Healthier Than the Real Thing?

We break down whether you should eat the meat or not.

Faux Fancy Appetizers

Add a celebratory note to your awards party table with these appetizer upgrades.

The Easy Snack Valerie's Mom Would Make 'Just Because She Loved Us'

Valerie Bertinelli shares a family recipe that's a perfect treat to make for the people you love.

How To Eat More Protein in Just 7 Days

Overwhelmed by all the info out there on this macronutrient? Our expert-written, on-demand newsletter series can help.