Looking for Mr. Goodbar Sundaes

These sundaes taste like Mr. Goodbar candy bars. I used to look for mini Goodbars first in my Trick-o-Treat bag.
Save Recipe
  • Level: Easy
  • Total: 11 min
  • Prep: 10 min
  • Cook: 1 min
  • Yield: 4 servings
Share This Recipe


2 pints vanilla ice cream

1 jar chocolate fudge sauce

1 cup red skinned salted peanuts, available on snack aisle of market

1/4 cup honey

Whipped cream, canister

8 mini chocolate covered crunchy peanut bar (recommended: Mr. Goodbar), optional garnish


  1. Get 4 sundae cups or goblets out and place a huge scoop of ice cream in each. Heat the fudge sauce 30 seconds in microwave, with the lid off the jar. Sprinkle a handful of nuts into each dish, top with a layer of fudge, another scoop of ice cream, a spoonful more of fudge. Heat the honey in microwave 10 to 15 seconds. Top sundaes with whipped cream, a drizzle of warm honey, then garnish with a few red peanuts and a couple of mini candy bars at the edge of the cup or goblet. edge. Serve with long spoons if you got them on plates, to catch any overflow.

Spanish Sundaes

Guinness Sundaes

Toasted Almond Sundaes

Caramel Pecan Sundaes

Chocolate Monkey Sundae

Chocolate and Vanilla Sundaes

Cran-applesauce Sundaes

Fruit Crunch Sundae