12 Days of Cookies: Sunny's PB and J Thumbprints

By: Melanie Rehak

It's time for 12 Days of Cookies, FoodNetwork.com's annual cookie swap. Each day visit us here on the Dish for a peek at new holiday cookies, party-planning tips and top techniques for rolling, spooning, slicing, baking and decorating delicious sweet treats to give – or keep – from favorite Food Network chefs. Then visit Cooking Channel's blog for great takes on holiday baking from Cooking Channel chefs and Food People alike – cookies by the dozen to celebrate all season.

You’ll never look at peanut butter and jelly the same way after trying Sunny Anderson’s thumbprint cookies. Ingredients that might seem humble become festive when you make a peanut butter cookie dough, roll each ball in sugar for a sparkly effect, then add a dollop of strawberry preserves in the center before baking. Just like that, a staple of childhood lunches is transformed into a grown-up dessert.

Get Sunny's recipe and check out dozens and dozens of batches in 12 Days of Cookies for more sweet ideas. Then tell us what you're baking.

Melanie Rehak, author of Eating for Beginners, has been baking cookies since she was old enough to climb onto the kitchen stool. She and her family are partial to Zimtsterne—cinnamon stars—for the holidays, but love cookies of all kinds all year long.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Cake Mix Holiday Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Use moist yellow cake mix to replace some of the usual ingredients in cookie batter to create soft holiday cookies.

Giada’s Holiday Biscotti — 12 Days of Cookies

These light and crunchy Italian biscotti get their famed crispiness from a double baking process. Get Giada's recipe.

Jeff Mauro's PB and J Blondie — 12 Days of Cookies

Get the recipe for Jeff Mauro's PB and J Blondie, part of Food Network's 12 Days of Cookies.

Sunny's Cereal Confetti Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Celebrate the holiday season with Sunny's Cereal Confetti Cookies.

Healthier Holiday Cookies

There are many ways to go about holiday cookie-making without gobs of butter and sugar—really, there are! Here are some ways to indulge sensibly.

Melissa’s Delicate Mint Sandwich Holiday Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Melissa nestles a cool mint-butter filling between two tangy cream-cheese based sugar cookies and dusts them with fine colored sugar.

Sunny Anderson's Ginger-Molasses Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Buttery, chewy and perfectly spiced, Sunny Anderson's Ginger-Molasses Cookies are just the recipe to round out your holiday cookie tray.

Brownie Cookies — 12 Days of Cookies

Food Network Kitchen's Brownie Cookies are the best of both worlds, thanks to their crunchy-chewy edges and moist, fudgy center.