Depending on the number of guests, make more cheese fish and starfish! Here's how to make The Kitchen's inspired version of this recipe: For the shark head, combine softened herbed cream cheese and shredded Monterey jack cheese. Shape the mixture into a triangle on the board. Add candy eyeballs, red pepper jelly as the inside of the mouth and cut jicama into teeth. Make a 1/2-inch border of poppy seeds around the edge of the shark head. Fill the remaining space on the board with sea creature treats, like Cheddar and pepper jack cheese cut into fish shapes, Cheddar and pretzel fish crackers and salami slices folded and nestled together to make a wave-like effect. Use blueberries, blackberries and grapes to fill in between everything as the water.