Papa Johns Joins Forces With a Popular Bagel Chain on Limited-Edition Schmears

Pizza and bagel lovers will want to try them ASAP.

August 26, 2026
Follow Casey on:

As a born and raised New Yorker, I know a thing or two about bagels and pizza. If you put both of those together, then I'm an expert. Now, when I received word that Papa Johns was collaborating with PopUp Bagels on limited-edition schmears, I was hooked.

What are the Papa Johns x PopUp Bagels schmears?

For a limited time, Papa Johns is collaborating with PopUp Bagels on not one, but two limited-time schmears that taste like classics from the pizza chain that fans know and love. Spoiler alert: They take the definition of a pizza bagel to the next level.

Here's a bit more on the two flavors you'll be able to get your hands on:

Pepperoncini Cream Cheese Schmear: Inspired by Papa Johns signature side pepperoncinis (which come complimentary with every pizza), this cream cheese schmear has a mild pickle tang, subtle heat and a smooth texture. It's perfect for a kick to start your morning.

Garlic Butter Schmear: There's nothing more delicious than dipping your pizza crust in Papa Johns' signature garlic sauce. This schmear draws inspiration from this beloved signature garlic sauce and packs a punch. It's creamy and slightly salty, and offers a balanced garlic flavor.

Where can you get the Papa Johns x PopUp Bagels schmears?

You'll want to run, not walk, to your local Papa Johns over the next two weeks to get these schmears. The Pepperoncini Cream Cheese Schmear will be available starting tomorrow, August 27, followed by the Garlic Butter Schmear on September 3.

Also, for Papa Johns fans in Atlanta, PopUp Bagels is going to “pop up” at a location to give out complimentary bagels and schmears while supplies last, alongside a few other surprises the brands are cooking up.

Related Content:

Next Up

Dave’s Killer Bread Releases Their Limited Edition Summer Berry Bagels

Made with four types of berries, these limited edition bagels are available through July.

Goldfish and Pokémon Drop Limited-Edition Collectible Packs

These Goldfish crackers look like Bulbasaur, Charmander, Squirtle and Pikachu.

New Doritos Cool Ranch Papadias Are Coming to Papa Johns

They’re a cool, tangy, creative take on the chip and sandwich experience.

Oreo Is Releasing a Limited-Edition Flavor with BTS

Here's where to get them before they're gone.

Ritz and Oreo Join Forces to Satisfy Your Sweet-Salty Snack Cravings

The limited-edition drop will only be available online.

Crayola Is Releasing Limited-Edition Sodas in a Rainbow of Colors

If you've ever wondered what Razzmatazz would taste like, now's your chance to find out.

7-Eleven Drops Limited-edition Fall Slurpee Flavor

We’ll be sipping on tart Green Apple all season long.

Oreo Is Releasing a Limited-Edition Flavor With Selena Gomez

It tastes like childhood comfort, she says.

What's New