Frozen Yogurt: Is it Healthy?

Making healthy choices isn’t always easy. In this new series, we’re diving into some seemingly better-for-you foods to explore  if they're really healthy.  To fire things up for summer, is cool and creamy fro-yo a healthy pick?
Yes?

Using yogurt instead of cream typically means a significant reduction in fat and calories. A half-cup serving of frozen yogurt will typically average 100 to 140 calories and zero to 3 grams of fat (a very reasonable sweet treat for any healthy diet). Some premium brands of ice cream contain 3 times more calories and 5 times more fat than frozen yogurt! Our taste test revealed that beneficial probiotic bacteria are present in frozen yogurt (a bonus for your digestive system). Nutrients like calcium, vitamin D and protein can also be found. Tart yogurt shops like Pinkberry and Red Mango are popping up across the country -- just remember that while the tart yogurts do have a unique flavor they’re still sweetened with sugar and have a similar amount of calories per serving to other types of frozen yogurt.

No?

Frozen yogurt still stacks up equally to ice cream when you look at the sugar content.  One half cup of vanilla averages 2 to 3 teaspoons of sugar. Top with extra goodies like cookies and candy the sugar content will be jacked up as well.

Is Fat-Free Better?

Nonfat varieties need to use thickeners and binders like carrageenan, cellulose and guar gum to make up for the texture that high fat ingredients like cream naturally provide. While these additives are very safe to eat, they do make some varieties of yogurt more processed than ice cream.

The Verdict

Frozen yogurt certainly does have healthy attributes like less calories and fat and some healthy bacteria but there’s a lot of variation in the sea of frozen yogurt options. Whether you’re at the local yogurt shop or picking up pints at the grocery store – seek out nutrition info and read ingredient labels carefully. Portion control is still key - choose "small" or "child" sizes when eating out and scoop out no more than a cup when at home. One of the healthiest routes may be to make your own.

TELL US: Is frozen yogurt your frosty treat of choice?

Dana Angelo White, MS, RD, ATC, is a registered dietitian, certified athletic trainer and owner of Dana White Nutrition, Inc., which specializes in culinary and sports nutrition. See Dana's full bio »

You Might Also Like:

Next Up

Nutrition News: Greek Yogurt Is in Schools (But Is It Beneficial?) and Junk Food Does Serious Damage

Greek yogurt heads to the cafeteria, a study questions yogurt health benefits, and five days of junk food messes with metabolism more than you might expect.

Hummus: Is it Healthy?

Find out if hummus is really a healthy choice.

How Bad Is It?

Summertime grilling season is the time of year when relaxed vibes give way to relaxed habits and maybe even a few missteps. Don't worry, we're here to let you know just how bad some of your little foibles are. We're answering the question "How Bad Is It?" and putting your backyard fumbles into 1 of 3 categories, "Not So Bad," "Pretty Bad," and "Really Bad."

Couscous: Is It Healthy?

This Mediterranean grain has become a popular side dish. But should couscous be making a regular appearance on your plate?

Popcorn: Is It Healthy?

The answer to this question: it depends. There are so many types to choose from-- kettle corn, movie popcorn, microwave, air-popped and pre-popped, flavored varieties. Some choices are definitely much healthier than others.

Cheese: Is It Healthy?

Does this dairy delight have a place in your healthy eating plan? Although cheese has gotten bad press for being high in artery-clogging fat, choosing the right ones can provide important nutrients to your diet.

Is It Healthy: Sushi?

Sushi seems like a healthy choice; it's made fish, veggies and rice . . . but is it really all that good for you?

Guacamole: Is It Healthy?

Should guacamole be part of a healthy Cinco celebration?

Ketchup: Is It Healthy?

Ketchup goes with just about everything—French fries, eggs, hash browns, burgers, deli meats...the list goes on and on. But is this red condiment good for you?

How Bad Is It?

Everyone has a few so-called "unhealthy habits," so we're letting you know just how bad they really are. These faux-pas fall into one of 3 categories, Not So Bad, Pretty Bad or Really Bad.