Photo: Emile Wamsteker ©
1 / 17
The Smoked-Out Asylum
In Season 2, Michelle Antonishek was crowned Halloween Baking Champion after creating this deliciously unnerving gingerbread house.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Emile Wamsteker ©
2 / 17
Gothic Gingerbread Mansion
In the season 2 finale, Tamara Brown created this towering gothic mansion out of gingerbread.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Eddy Chen ©
3 / 17
Apocalyptic Apartment Cake
In season 1, Rudy Martinez won the competition with this cinnamon cake with fig buttercream, white chocolate ganache and buttermilk caramel toxic waste.
More photos after this Ad
Worst Nightmare Cake
In Season 4, Lyndsy McDonald presents her dish from the main heat to the judges.
More photos after this Ad
Let's Make a Deal Cake
In season 3, Jasmin Bell took home the win with her intricate and spooky light up chocolate cake.
More photos after this Ad
Witch and Goblin Wedding Cake
In season 4, Lyndsy McDonald celebrated the wedding of a witch and goblin with a delicious margarita wedding cake. The judges loved the bubbling cauldron and the glistening heart.
More photos after this Ad
Zombie Pumpkin Patch
In season 4, Michelle Honeman created a zombie pumpkin patch out of apple bundt cakes by glazing them with a green ganache and decorating them with creepy candy eyeballs.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Emile Wamsteker ©
8 / 17
Zombie Hand Cheesecake
In season 2, Amy Strickland created this grotesque creation. "No zombie hand is complete without maggots," said Amy, who created a rice cereal and fondant replica with gaping wounds to top her mocha raspberry cheesecake.
More photos after this Ad
Slasher Pumpkin Cake
In season 4, Jamal Lake turned his cute pumpkin cake into a slasher cake with just a few well-placed lines and some red frosting. Carla called it "incredible."
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Sarrah Danziger
10 / 17
Rat Passion Fruit Almond Tart
In season 3, Jessica Scott's created this rat-themed passion fruit almond tart with meringue and spaghetti bark.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Tyler Golden ©
11 / 17
Two-Headed Turtle Cake
In season 2, Tamara made this two-headed turtle cake. Damiano called the black and green marble cake with chocolate sandwich cookie filling the best he's tasted.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Sarrah Danziger
12 / 17
Werewolf Cake
In season 3, Jasmin Bell modeled this stunning abstract cake after a spooky werewolf mask.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Emile Wamsteker
13 / 17
Zombie Tart
In season 2, Brad Rudd made this disturbing chocolate chai spice tart with raspberries. "I want it to feel like a zombie ripped someone's face off," said Brad. We think he succeeded.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Sarrah Danziger
14 / 17
Eyeball Scream Puffs
In season 3, Jessica Scott created these unsettling eyeball cream puffs swimming in a pool of strawberry coulis blood.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Eddy Chen ©
15 / 17
Monster Cinnamon Rolls
In season 1, Erin Cooper created these adorable cinnamon rolls topped with monster cookies.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Sarrah Danziger
16 / 17
Zombie Scream Puffs
In season 3, Jasmin Bell created these all-seeing zombie-themed cream puffs with peanut butter cream and raspberry jam.
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Sarrah Danziger
17 / 17
Spider Surprise Cookies
In season 3, Dina Melendez's spider-themed lemon-lime sugar cookies spilled out bone candy and black licorice when they were cracked in half.