Caramel Popcorn Balls — The Weekender

By: Marisa McClellan
Related To:

Each year around Halloween I find myself feeling nostalgic for elementary school — for class parties, costume parades on the playground and a plastic pumpkin bursting with candy. I also find myself craving my mom’s honeyed popcorn. It was her signature treat to give to friends and neighbors for the holiday.

After dinner when all the dishes were cleaned and put away, she’d fire up our yellow-and-white air popper and keep it running until she had filled a clean brown paper grocery bag with the popped corn. Once that task was finished, she’d melt butter and honey together into a thick syrup and pour it over the popped corn, using her longest-handled wooden spoon to help stir it all up.

The sweetened corn would then get spread across rimmed cookie sheets and would go into the oven for 10 or 15 minutes, to help set and crisp the kernels. The next day when it was cool, she’d package it up in plastic bags, secured with orange and black twist ties. My sister and I always got small bags in our lunch the day after she made it.

This year as Halloween drifts ever closer, I’ve been craving sweetened popcorn. Though I love my mom’s honey-butter combination, I thought it would be fun to try my hand at a more traditional popcorn ball (the version my mom always made wasn’t quite sticky enough to hold a ball shape). I settled on Marcela Valladolid's recipe for Caramel Popcorn Balls. What attracted me is that it includes honey, so I knew it would recall the popcorn from my elementary school days.

Making the popcorn balls was fun and very sticky. They tasted like harvest festivals and school carnivals and are just the thing to do this Saturday after you’ve carved your pumpkin and toasted the seeds — that's what makes this recipe perfect for The Weekender.

Before you start popping your corn, here are a few things you should know:

- Marcela instructs you to use microwave popcorn for these balls. I’ve heard some unsavory things about the chemicals in those bags and so opted to pop mine on the stovetop. If you do the same, you’re looking for 5-6 cups of popped corn.

- Please be careful with the caramel. It gets very hot and can leave nasty burns if it touches your skin while still hot. After you pour it over the corn, wait the full 5 minutes before attempting to form the balls.

- If you have helpers with this project, make sure that hands are washed, sleeves are rolled up and hair is well-secured before getting near the sticky caramel.

- If you’re not going to serve the popcorn balls right away, make sure to store them in an airtight container once cool.

Marisa McClellan is a food writer and canning teacher who lives in Center City Philadelphia. Find more of her food (all cooked up in her 80-square-foot kitchen) at her blog, Food in Jars. Her first cookbook, Food in Jars: Canning in Small Batches Year Round,  is now available.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Spooky Halloween Punch Recipes

Conjure up a good time with one of these party-perfect potions.

Beyond Tricks and Treats: Savory Recipes for Halloween

Check out Food Network's favorite savory recipes for your Halloween party.

French Fries Costume

The wardrobe whiz from Good Eats with Alton Brown dreams up Halloween costumes for little food lovers.

Best 5 Halloween Treats

Check out Food Network's top-five spooktacular Halloween treats from The Pioneer Woman, Alton Brown, Giada De Laurentiis and more chefs.

Halloween Wars Q&As: Hear from the Team Members of 2 Ghouls and a Guy

Hear from the members of 2 Ghouls and a Guy, one of five teams competing on Halloween Wars, Season 5.

Candy Man: How to Make Alton Brown's Candy Corn

Alton Brown makes candy corn for Food Network Magazine, step-by-step.

Special Guest Judges Scare on a New Season of Halloween Wars

Halloween Wars returns for Season 4 with all-new episodes starting Sunday, Oct. 5 at 9|8c. Read on for a list of special guest judges.

Halloween Costumes Good Enough to Eat

Celebrate your child's love of culinary creations by making him a Halloween costume of his favorite food. These foodie costumes are almost good enough to eat.