After 3 Long Years, A Fan-Favorite Pop-Tarts Flavor Is Coming Back — Permanently

Plus, three new ones arrive with a protein boost.

October 15, 2025

Photo by: Image Courtesy of Pop-Tarts

Image Courtesy of Pop-Tarts

The genius of finding a winning format for food is that there can be all kinds of flavor variations. Just ask Doritos or Oreo. Pop-Tarts are no exception, offering toaster-compatible rectangular pastries in dozens of filling and topping combinations. However, the downside of providing so many options to consumers is that, sometimes, a particular product can no longer be manufactured. And discontinuation means disappointing the fervent fans of whatever is being axed.

Such was the case with Frosted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop-Tarts which, sadly, started disappearing from store shelves years ago. They were officially discontinued in 2022. Fans started a petition, and online chatter demanded their return. And now, Pop-Tarts has finally delivered, bringing back the cookie dough-inspired filling and swirled chocolate icing fans will remember.

When are Frosted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop-Tarts coming back?

Starting in November, Pop Tarts Frosted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough will be returning to stores nationwide — and they’ll remain a permanent flavor. You’ll be able to buy an eight-count box for $3.49.

“Our fans continue to show us how passionate they are about their favorite flavors, which is how we knew it was time for Frosted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough to make a comeback,” Leslie Serro, Vice President of Marketing for Pop-Tarts, says.

Photo by: Image Courtesy of Pop-Tarts

Image Courtesy of Pop-Tarts

What else is Pop-Tarts releasing?

Also dropping in November is Pop-Tarts’ latest innovation, which jumps upon the increasingly prominent protein trend. According to descriptions provided by Pop-Tarts, the three new protein-enhanced flavors are:

  • Pop-Tarts Protein Slammin’ Strawberry: Tart strawberry filling, a golden crust and frosting topped with rainbow sprinkles.
  • Pop-Tarts Protein Boostin’ Brown Sugar Cinnamon: A gooey brown sugar cinnamon filling, golden-brown crust and a crisp, sweet frosting finish.
  • Pop-Tarts Protein Bumpin’ Blueberry: A jam-like blueberry center topped with sweet icing and crunchy sprinkles.

Pop-Tarts Protein look and sound a lot like regular Pop-Tarts. However, they will offer roughly double the protein of the regular pastries. According to a Pop-Tarts spokesperson, the serving size of two pastries (one pouch) will include 10 grams of protein from a combination of milk protein and wheat protein. We suppose we won’t be surprised if we start seeing Pop-Tarts pop up in people’s gym bags.

Protein Pop-Tarts will be sold nationwide for a suggested retail price of $3.99 per eight-count box.

Related Content:

Next Up

After Three Long Years, Chipotle Is Bringing back Fan-Favorite Smoked Brisket

Like when it first launched, the protein will only be available for a limited time.

A Fan-Favorite Dr Pepper Flavor Is Coming Back

The summery sip’s fans are excited: ‘Best soda I ever had.’

A Fan-Favorite Protein Is Coming Back to Chipotle

Customers have been demanding its return since last year.

These Fan-Favorite Cheerios Are Coming Back for a Limited Time

This citrusy cereal is perfect for summer, so enjoy it while you can.

2 Fan-Favorite Doughnuts Are Coming Back to Krispy Kreme

The summer menu also includes new frozen drinks.

After 6 Long Years, McDonald’s Is Bringing Back One of Its Best Deals

Here are the items that will be included in the chain’s Extra Value Meals menu.

An Iconic Diet Coke Flavor Is Finally Coming Back

Coca-Cola is also dropping a new flavor inspired by an ice cream treat.

What's New