5 Stunning Cakes with Sky-High Fan Reviews

Fans have spoken, and these 5-star cakes, with hundreds or even thousands of reviews, totally deserve their place on a pedestal.
Beatty's Chocolate Cake

Cooking Channel Ina Garten Beattys Chocolate Cake

Photo by: Marshall Troy Photography ©2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Right Reserved.

Marshall Troy Photography, 2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Right Reserved.

Hey, if you're going to go to the trouble of sifting, measuring, whisking, preheating, baking, layering, frosting and slicing (we're exhausted just  typing all of that) to get your cake fix, it better be worth it. So when it comes to picking just the right recipe, you better go for one that's tried-and-true. The people have spoken, and these freshly baked beauties totally deserve their place on a pedestal. As of this moment, these cakes have a seriously stunning amount of shining reviews (and the numbers are only going up).

2,014 Reviews: Beatty's Chocolate Cake

The numbers don't lie. Thousands of fans agree that Ina Garten's chocolatey dream of a cake (pictured above) is simply the best. It achieves a deeply decadent richness with a secret-weapon ingredient: a cup of freshly brewed coffee in the batter.

The Ultimate Cheesecake
653 Reviews: The Ultimate Cheesecake

Tyler Florence's creamy, berry-topped beauty gets its name for a reason: It's seriously the ultimate cheesecake you could ever hope to bake. It's got a homemade graham cracker crust and an expertly executed cream cheese filling, spiked with lemon zest and made even creamier with a cup of sour cream.

Carrot and Pineapple Cake


A good carrot cake is always a crowd favorite, and Ina's fruity, jam-packed recipe is here to prove it with hundreds of shining reviews. A whole pound of grated carrots goes into the batter for Ina's fan-favorite recipe, but that's not even the half of it. This cake is also loaded up with chewy raisins, crunchy walnuts, and juicy and fresh pineapple, so each bite is extra-chunky — and goes perfectly with classic cream cheese frosting.

Big Chocolate Birthday Cake

At a towering four layers, Ree's sky-high chocolate creation is perfect for birthdays, with its moist, buttermilk-rich cake and airy frosting.

Lemon Yogurt Cake
667 Reviews: Lemon Yogurt Cake

Ina's lemony loaf cake doesn't need a bunch of fluffy frosting to garner hundreds of reviews. Her recipe calls for vegetable oil and yogurt instead of butter for added moistness, and its bright, citrusy flavor screams spring with every slice.

Quick Vanilla Buttercream

FN_Gale Gand Quick Vanilla Buttercream

FN_Gale Gand Quick Vanilla Buttercream

©2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

2012, Television Food Network, G.P. All Rights Reserved.

Bonus recipe! For many, the most-important part of any cake is the slathering of frosting. This classic vanilla-flavored buttercream is simply the best, and it can be used to top just about any cake, cupcake or even cookie you bake.

Get more cake recipes from our friends in #ComfortFoodFeast:

Creative Culinary:  St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
Red or Green:  Spiced Gingerbread Cake
In Jennie's Kitchen:  Dark Chocolate Brownies

Next Up

4 Easy Ways to Be a Better Cake Baker Right Now

You need some planning, some patience — and this cheap, must-have tool.

This Shapeshifting Cake Batter Is the Ultimate Party Trick

With this genius base recipe, if you can make one cake flavor, you can make six — and just by adding, never subtracting or swapping.

Relax, It's Just a Layer Cake

The key to picture-perfect cakes? Don’t overmix, don't overbake, and follow these easy assembly tips.

How to Make Milk Bar's Famous Birthday Cake

We stopped by Milk Bar's test kitchen location in Brooklyn to see how the masterpiece comes together.

The Perfect Frosting for Every Cake

Learn the how-tos for making rich, silky frosting with this handy guide.

Lemon-Lime Pound Cake — The Weekender

Fight back against the wintertime blues with tart, tangy citrus. Ree's Lemon-Lime Pound Cake can satisfy your sweet tooth and brighten your day.

Cakes: Tips and Techniques

Use this guide to make baking a cake, well, a piece of cake.

Cream Cheese Frosting, 7 Different Ways

Learn how to make classic cream cheese frosting, then apply it to your favorite cake and cupcake recipes.

Orange Poppy Bundt Cake — Bake-Ahead Batches

Tangy buttermilk, fragrant orange zest and plenty of poppy seeds add deep flavor to this moist, tender-crumbed cake.