31 Stuffed Mushroom Recipes That Make the Perfect Appetizer
Updated on October 13, 2026
Serve your guests a satisfying starter (that won't overshadow the main meal) with everything from sausage-stuffed caps to vegetarian options.
How To Make Stuffed Mushrooms
Don't forget the appetizers when you're hosting! While most of the attention will go to the main meal, it's always good to have some easy small bites on hand for when guests arrive — especially if an inevitable cooking mishap occurs. That's where stuffed mushrooms come in. Whether you're having friends over for a dinner party or gathering the family for a Turkey Day feast, this classic appetizer is sure to be a hit.
Ina's stuffed mushrooms are always a good idea when cooking for a group. She marinates her mushrooms in Marsala wine and olive oil before adding a sweet Italian sausage filling to create multiple layers of flavor. You can always count on Ina to serve crowd-pleasing dishes the whole gathering will love, and this recipe is no exception!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Matt Armendariz
2 / 31
3-Ingredient Stuffed Mushrooms
These flavor-packed mushrooms prove you don’t need a fridge full of ingredients to whip up a winning appetizer. We chose garlic-and-herb soft cheese as the stuffing base for its famously creamy texture and savory flavor. Panko breadcrumbs do double duty, first mixed into the filling to help absorb the flavorful mushroom juices and then as an easy coating to give the mushrooms a classic crunchy top.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Stuffed White Mushrooms with Pecan Breadcrumbs
Alex says, "The nuts amplify the taste of the mushrooms and bring out the garlic and onions note in the mushrooms. These can be made in advance and simply heated and served when ready to eat."
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: GEOFF GEORGE
4 / 31
Garlic and Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms
Mary abides by the steakhouse ethos for side dishes: stuff it and coat it in cheese! It’s an adaptably delicious rule for these cheesy, garlicky mushrooms. Serve them as an appetizer or a delicious side—either way, they're guaranteed to be gobbled up.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: KATE MATHIS
5 / 31
Air Fryer Stuffed Mushrooms
Oven space is prime real estate on Thanksgiving day, making your air fryer an extra-valuable tool These mushrooms, stuffed with garlicky, cheesy breadcrumbs, make a perfect appetizer for turkey day. Plus, you can make them all on your countertop!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Artichoke Dip-Stuffed Mushrooms
Kardea says, "Spinach-artichoke dip is always a hit when I serve it at parties, so I knew it would be the perfect filling for mushrooms. If you want to make these ahead of time, you can make the dip, fill the mushrooms, and then bake them just before it's time for the party."
GET THE RECIPE
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Photography by MacKenzie Kelley
7 / 31
Mushroom-Stuffed Mushrooms
The secret to these extra flavorful bites? Stuffing the mushrooms with more mushrooms — specifically, chopped-up mushroom stems, which, along with quinoa, retain moisture and soak up the garlic juice and Parmesan cheese exceptionally well.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
8 / 31
Sausage and Squash Stuffed Mushrooms with Cornbread Crumbs
Cornbread stands in for breadcrumbs in these delectable stuffed mushrooms. White mushrooms are filled with a hearty combination of butternut squash, breakfast sausage, and cornbread crumbles. Scallions and Asiago cheese add tons of flavor, too!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Matt Armendariz
9 / 31
Stuffed Mushroom Dip
This creamy dip has all the sausage-and-mushroom flavor of stuffed mushroom caps—perfect for any gathering. Plus, it saves you the hassle of stuffing individual mushrooms! Serve with toasted baguette slices for dipping!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Sunny's Spinach and Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms
Sunny Anderson’s Spinach and Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms are a flavorful starter filled with garlicky spinach and melty cheese. These golden, savory bites are crowd-pleasers that disappear fast from the appetizer tray.
GET THE RECIPE
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
11 / 31
Cheesy Carrot and Tofu Stuffed Mushrooms
There is no such thing as too much cheese—especially when it comes to stuffed mushrooms. The filling for these mushrooms contain both Parmesan and pepper Jack for maximum cheesiness. Carrots and tofu add sweetness and heft, respectively, without the need for meat.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Crispy Brie-Stuffed Mushrooms
Ree knows it's not a party until the Brie comes out — so she packs this beloved cheese into a simple party-perfect bite that guests can nibble on before dinner.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
13 / 31
Double Stuffed Mushrooms
Pro tip: Make some extra stuffing while preparing for Thanksgiving, and use it to stuff mushrooms! By using stuffing you already have, you'll cut down on the prep work—and have a nice appetizer to serve! They're a great vessel for leftover stuffing after the big day, too.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Matt Armendariz ©
14 / 31
Stuffed Mushrooms
These delicate stuffed mushrooms make it easy to snack while mingling at a Thanksgiving cocktail hour. Create the perfect bowl shape to accomodate the stuffing by using a melon baller to gently scoop out the stem from inside the mushroom caps. Look for wide mushroom caps when shopping so they're big enough to stuff!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
15 / 31
Feta and Spinach Stuffed Mushrooms
These stuffed mushrooms are simple but absolutely packed with flavor. Feta cheese is just the right amount of salty, while whole wheat breadrumbs add depth. For color and freshness, incorporate spinach and fresh basil into the stuffing as well!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Teri Lyn Fisher
16 / 31
Stuffed Mushroom Stuffing
This is the stuffing for mushroom lovers. All the savory flavors of stuffed mushrooms are incorporated into the cubed-bread casserole itself, including sausage, diced bell pepper, scallions, parsley and thyme. Then the top gets covered with individual stuffed mushroom caps for an irresistible presentation that’s bound to wow. Plenty of broth and butter keep the stuffing juicy and moist, while a topping of panko and Parmesan gets wonderfully browned and crispy for a classic stuffing contrast.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Matt Armendariz
17 / 31
Double-Crisp Stuffed Mushrooms
These over-the-top stuffed baby bella mushrooms have a savory, herby and cheesy filling plus an incredibly crispy frico topping. That’s because once these beauties are stuffed, we flip each one its head and place it on top of a spoonful of umami-packed Parmesan. While the mushrooms bake, the bottom gets irresistible golden brown and crisp. The result: Tender, cheesy stuffed mushroom with a double crispy top that’s perfect for every gathering.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Stuffed Mushrooms
Need a 5-star app for your holiday table? Valerie's stuffed mushrooms are sure to be a hit. She incorporates baby spinach and cherry tomatoes for a touch of freshness and color. Plus, these mushrooms don't have sausage in the filling, which is a nice change of pace from traditional recipes.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Ryan Dausch
19 / 31
Cornbread-Chorizo Stuffed Mushrooms
If cornbread stuffing is your favorite part of Thanksgiving dinner, these stuffed mushrooms are for you. These bite-size treats taste like the classic stuffing in mushroom form. However, we think the cheddar cheese and pickled jalapeños might give these stuffed mushrooms a slight edge over the classic side dish.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Bacon and Goat Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms
Looking for an elevated appetizer? These mushroom caps are stuffed with bacon, tangy fresh goat cheese and chives. Instead of traditional breadcrumbs, use crumbled challah for a little something extra.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Jalapeño Popper-Stuffed Mushrooms
Here are the comforting flavors of jalapeño poppers transformed into a sophisticated, crowd-pleasing stuffed mushroom. Better yet? This surprising mash-up includes another perennial favorite: bacon.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Renee Comet
22 / 31
Stuffed Mushroom Casserole
Save yourself the hassle of stuffing individual mushrooms and make this casserole instead! You get all the flavors of the classic dish with a fraction of the prep time. Plus, it makes for a great side dish on the Thanksgiving table.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
23 / 31
Sweet and Savory Stuffed Mushrooms
These stuffed mushrooms are a fun twist on classic savory options. Dried apricots add a touch of sweetness, but the flavor is balanced by bacon and provolone. Chopped walnuts bulk up the filling and add a nice crunch.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Andouille and Cornbread Stuffed Mushrooms
You don't need Italian sausage for a great mushroom filling! These mushroom caps are stuffed with smoky andouille, spicy pickled jalapeño and Cheddar. You get a ton of flavor in each and every bite!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Ryan Dausch
25 / 31
French Onion Soup Stuffed Mushrooms
Filled with caramelized onions and topped with gooey Gruyère, these classy appetizers capture the decadent goodness of French onion soup in one bite. The caramelized onions take extra time, but it's well worth it. These mushrooms are gooey, cheesy, and just the right amount of sweet and savory.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Armando Rafael
26 / 31
Spicy Italian Stuffed Mushrooms
Looking to turn up the heat? The filling for these stuffed mushrooms incorporates both pepperoncini and spicy Italian sausage. You'll get a nice amount of spice that's still appropriate for guests who prefer mild dishes.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Spinach Artichoke Dip Stuffed Mushrooms
Katie says, "Stuffed mushrooms and spinach artichoke dip—two of the best appetizers, in my opinion, so why not put them together? These are sure to be the hit of the cocktail hour and really perfect to make ahead. You can either keep them in the fridge and pop in the oven before serving, or freeze them and bake a little longer from frozen."
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Ryan Liebe ©
28 / 31
Fondue Stuffed Mushrooms
Two appetizers combine into one delicious dish! Gooey raclette is the star of the filling for these mushroom caps. Buttery, garlicky breadcrumbs and fresh parsley make up the rest of this cheesy, crunchy stuffing.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Stuffed Mushrooms with Pine Nuts and Golden Raisins
Upgrade your Thanksgiving appetizers with these stuffed mushrooms, featuring both pine nuts and golden raisins. The savory, nutty filling pairs perfectly with the tender, earthy mushrooms for a bite-sized treat that's both flavorful and sophisticated. Don't expect any leftovers!
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Photo: Ryan Dausch
30 / 31
Crispy Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
Cream cheese, chopped veggies and fresh lemon make bright additions to this crab filling. It would make a wonderful dip on its own, but it’s even better when baked into mushrooms with buttery cracker crumbs. The cracker crumbs get crisp in the oven, which makes these stuffed mushrooms irresistable.
get the recipe
More photos after this Ad
Spicy Bacon and Spinach Stuffed Mushrooms
We take some of our favorite omelet fillings (bacon, spinach and mushrooms) and use them to make one fantastic appetizer! Mozzarella cheese makes the filling gooey and tender, which is even better when baked until golden brown. Serve warm!
get the recipe