How to Use Cookie Cutters to Carve a Pumpkin

Give everyone who passes your stoop a pumpkin to talk about this Halloween!

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.
September 08, 2020

Related To:

Pumpkin carving is an essential fall activity. Whether you choose to carve yours at the very beginning of October or you save it for Halloween night, there’s no doubt you’re in for a really scary time. Though we’re big fans of traditional carved Jack-o-lanterns, we also love shaking things up every year and exploring new ways to transform our Halloween pumpkins. Need proof? Just look at what we did with some broccoli and kale. This year, we’re taking things even further by using cookie cutters as stencils to turn our pumpkins into glow-in-the-dark lanterns. Here’s how you can get started right at home.

Scaredy Cat

Cut a wide hole in the bottom of a pumpkin and scoop out the seeds and flesh. Paint the pumpkin with black craft paint. Let dry, then using a pencil, trace the inside of a cat cookie cutter onto the center of the pumpkin. Place the cookie cutter on the shape you just traced and tap lightly with a rubber mallet until it cuts through the pumpkin.

Shooting Stars

Cut a wide hole in the bottom of a pumpkin and scoop out the seeds and flesh. Using a pen, trace the inside of different-size star cookie cutters onto the pumpkin, starting with the largest at the top and working diagonally down to the smallest. Place each cookie cutter on the corresponding shape and tap lightly with a rubber mallet until it cuts through the pumpkin.

Starry Night

Cut a wide hole in the bottom of a pumpkin and scoop out the seeds and flesh. Using a pen, trace the inside of different-size star cookie cutters onto the pumpkin in a random pattern. Place each cookie cutter on the corresponding shape and tap lightly with a rubber mallet until it cuts through the pumpkin.

Dotted Lines

Cut a wide hole in the bottom of a pumpkin and scoop out the seeds and flesh. Using a pen, trace the inside of a one-inch round cookie cutter onto the pumpkin so it forms a band around the middle, then trace the inside of progressively smaller cookie cutters to form bands above and below. Place each cookie cutter on the corresponding shape and tap lightly with a rubber mallet until it cuts through the pumpkin.

Falling Leaves

Cut a wide hole in the bottom of a pumpkin and scoop out the seeds and flesh. Using a pen, trace the inside of leaf cookie cutters onto the pumpkin so they form a band around the middle. Place each cookie cutter on the corresponding shape and tap lightly with a rubber mallet until it cuts through the pumpkin.

Related Links:

How to Decorate Halloween Pumpkins with Food

Next Up

Inventive New Ways to Use All Your Cookie Cutters This Christmas

Because ghost and pumpkin cutters aren't just for Halloween!

How to Upgrade School Lunches with Cookie Cutters

Go far, far beyond cookies. (OK, one cookie won't hurt.)

11 Unique Cookie Cutters to Make Holiday Baking Extra Fun

From cookie rollers to stamps, these cookie cutters will make your confectionary endeavors shine!

How To Use a Cookie Press

This handy baking tool can help you turn out perfectly uniform cookies — in dozens of fun shapes.

The Best Pasta Cutters for Every Noodle Shape

From fettuccine to fresh ravioli, slice your way to homemade pasta perfection with these handy tools.

How To Carve a Turkey in a Few Easy Steps

We'll walk you through everything you need to know to perfectly present the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving dinner.

Is America’s Favorite Holiday Cookie Even a Cookie?

Google’s 2025 search trends reveal what to expect at your holiday cookie swap.

Cookie Hacks

The crew at The Kitchen offer up some easy ways to create holiday cheer in your kitchen.

Cookie Packaging

For a fun and memorable gift presentation, try wrapping your holiday cookies in one of the following ways.

On TV

What's New