These Are the Best Keurig Coffee Pods You Can Buy Now

Coffee in 60 seconds never tasted so good!

Keep in mind: Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money from these affiliate links.
March 28, 2023

Related To:

Yellow mug in the hands of a young woman. Girl holding a Cup of coffee in a cafe. Coffee break, Breakfast. The concept of power. Close up.


Yellow mug in the hands of a young woman. Girl holding a Cup of coffee in a cafe. Coffee break, Breakfast. The concept of power. Close up.

Photo by: Aleksandr Zubkov

Aleksandr Zubkov

No matter how you take your cup of coffee, you can’t fight the ease and convenience of a Keurig machine — especially if you live in a small space or desire a cost-effective option. You could bust out your coffee grinder, kettle and French press, but you could also pick up a K-Cup and have freshly brewed coffee steaming in your hands in about 60 seconds. Not to mention, K-Cups have expanded to include some pretty delicious roast and flavor options from some of your go-to coffee brands and stores. Since there are so many options for K-Cups, we decided to taste-test 20 different varieties to find the best.

How We Tested

I got my husband and friend in on testing 20 different K-Cups with me, noting strength of brew, sweetness and overall coffee flavor. As a Keurig user, I have experience with tasting different Keurig coffees and felt confident picking these 20 to taste. In testing, we learned that a lot of coffees hide a general lack of flavoring under the guise of being a dark roast. We also found some of the flavor pods were way too sugary, while some were delightfully sweet. Below, we've rounded up our top seven K-Cups that any Keurig user should always have on-hand.

$39.95 for a pack of 48

Not only is this coffee low-acid, making it perfect for people with sensitive stomachs or acid-reflux, it was truly the best all-around cup of the day. All three of us completely agreed that it is well-balanced and smooth. It even has a hint of sweetness. Add that to the fact that the pods are compatible with both Keurig and Nespresso machines, and they’re biodegradable. You’re looking at the recipe for success, folks.

Buy It
$42.99 for a pack of 72

This is a medium blend that features notes of caramel and chocolate with little hints of smoke that makes it feel slightly like a French roast. Even with these bold flavors, it manages to be pretty light and, as my friend described it, "approachable."

Buy It
$51.99 for six boxes of 10

The famous pumpkin spice flavor! This guy isn’t as potent as the syrup-clad latte version that you purchase in stores, but it still smells like fall in a cup. The medium-roasted coffee features notes of blended pumpkin, cinnamon and nutmeg. It’s rich and hearty and a great way to integrate fall flavors into your morning drink without extra sweetness.

Buy It
$16.63 for pack of 20

Remember when the Keurig machines first came out and all you could think about was the fact that you could now brew a latte from home? This meets that expectation. It’s sugary-sweet, super frothy and milky. My friend even thought it was the best thing that we tried all day. One thing I will recommend — brew this on the 8-ounce setting instead of the 10-ounce, this way you get more of a coffee flavor.

Buy It
$52.88 for six boxes of 10

This is a great medium roast. It features notes of tropical fruit, but still manages to be super smooth and not too acidic. It’s definitely bold, so we would definitely add in a little milk and a dash of sugar to bring out the fruit flavors.

Buy It

How to Store Your K-Cups

If you're looking for the most effective way to store your K-Cups, we suggest a storage drawer that doubles as a stand for your machine. You'll keep everything organized in one spot, and, depending on which Keurig you have, you might also have space to store your favorite, go-to mugs on the side. Consider it the ideal coffee station set-up.

This article has been reviewed since its original publish date for accuracy, pricing and availability. We stand by our list of top K-Cup coffee pod flavor picks and are hopeful that Wandering Bear Extra Strong Pods, which were sold out at the time of review, will restock soon.

Related Content:

Next Up

The Pioneer Woman's Instant Pot Design Is a Fan-Favorite

Plus, this Instant Pot Lux is currently on sale!

The Best Alfredo Sauce to Buy in a Jar

Which sauce is actually worth grabbing off the shelf?

The Best Wedding Gifts Food Network Staffers Have Received

Sometimes the best gifts aren't on the registry.

The Best New Kitchen Tools We Tested in 2021

From genius cookware to easy-to-use appliances, these are the top-performing new kitchen appliances and cookware from this year.

The Best Spice Racks to Fit Every Kitchen

Whether you store your spices in the cabinet, on your countertop or in a drawer, there is an organizer to help!

How to Buy an At-Home Espresso Machine, According to a Coffee Expert

We reached out to a master barista for tips on picking the right machine.

5 Grocery Delivery Services Where You Can Buy in Bulk

Do bulk shopping from the comfort of your couch.

The Best Baskets for Your Summer Picnic

Not only are they cute, they're functional too!

This Is the Most Fun Way to Make Homemade Ice Cream

Kids will love this interactive ice cream maker!

What's New