Next Up

10 Times Bobby Won 'Beat Bobby Flay' With Dessert

November 16, 2026

Bobby Flay swears desserts are his weak point, but these wins — from puckery key lime pie to sticky toffee pudding — prove otherwise.

Price and stock could change after publish date, and we may make money off these affiliate links. Learn more.
Scroll For More Photos
1 / 11

Bobby the Baker

Bobby Flay is renowned for his top-notch tamales, juicy steaks, crispy rice and boundary-pushing burgers. (He’s the founder of a restaurant chain called Bobby’s Burgers, after all!) What do each of these recipes have in common? They’re savory. I was lucky enough to interview Bobby via Zoom a couple of years ago, and one of his most surprising confessions was when he conceded that dessert wasn’t exactly his sweet spot. In fact, Bobby admitted that “my dessert game is a little weak.”

But as I’ve been devouring episodes from the Beat Bobby Flay archives lately, I’ve been reminded of 10 challenges that act as convincing and delicious proof otherwise. Grab a snack and join us as we walk down memory lane and relive Bobby’s sweetest victories from the last decade.

More photos after this Ad

Photo: David M. Russell
2 / 11

His Apple Dumpling From ‘Sweet but Sour’

The Kitchen co-hosts Sunny Anderson and Katie Lee Biegel are among Bobby’s closest friends, so it’s no surprise that they were privy to his self-described shortcoming. “We know what you're not good at,” Sunny said tauntingly, referring to dessert, during Season 11’s “Sweet but Sour” episode. The dynamic duo introduced their Chicago-based pastry chef pals: Kym DeLost and Chris Teixeira. Bobby studied their “game tape” as the two whipped up white chocolate desserts a la minute.

Kym took the crown, then challenged Bobby to an apple dumpling contest. When Bobby turned away in disbelief, Kym asked, “Do you want to give up now?” Turns out, Bobby’s quite the apple aficionado. His Caramel Apple Cheesecake has an impressive five-star rating average, after more than 80 reviews. Kym’s Apple Dumplings With Brown Butter Custard impressed; however, Bobby’s Red Hot Apple Dumpling With Spiced Caramel Sauce stole the show with its buttery biscuit dough. “They didn’t think I could do it, but I proved them wrong,” Bobby said proudly.

Get His Five-Star Caramel Apple Cheesecake Recipe

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Stephen Davis Phillips
3 / 11

His Banana Cream Pie From ‘Salty and Sweet’

Katie was back for Season 12’s “Salty and Sweet” with another Bobby BFF: Southern food scholar Carla Hall. Carla’s strategy? “We have to find something that you don’t do so well.” Bobby countered, “Plenty of stuff. [I’m] not good at desserts.” Carla and Katie perked up, because both brought pastry chefs to challenge each other at Battle Raisin — then take on Bobby: James Beard Award nominee Bruno Feldeisen and cookbook author Michelle Gayer.

Michelle’s Raisin Crepe With Bourbon Mascarpone raised spirits enough to relay her into the next round, where she asked Bobby to bring his best Banana Cream Pie. Bobby’s Freeform Banana Cream Pie With Pecan Brittle wouldn’t win any beauty contests (“my 12-year-old could plate better than this,” one judge said), but it did deliver enough in the flavor department to top Michelle’s lightly flavored Roasted Banana Cream Pie With Malted Rum Whipped Cream. “You make a pie that literally falls apart,” Katie complained, “and you still win,” Carla concluded, with a sigh. As Bobby walked away with a smile, he told them, “There’s only one thing to say: that was bananas!”

Get the Recipe in the 'Beat Bobby Flay' Cookbook

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Chris Amaral
4 / 11

His Chocolate Tart From ‘Broken Hearts’

During Season 15, Chefs Anne Burrell and Scott Conant tried to leave Bobby with something that matched the episode title: a “Broken Heart.” Once again, they welcomed pastry pros, Holiday Wars winner Robert Nieto and cookbook author Caroline Schiff. Caroline and Robert faced off in a maraschino cherry competition. With her Mousse With Champagne Poached Cherries, Caroline lived up to her promise to Bobby: “I’m going to show you how to put the cherry on top.”

For Round 2, she asked Bobby to bring his best Chocolate Tart to the table. And bring it he did, with his well-balanced Chocolate Cherry Tart With Whipped Cream that ever-so-slightly topped Caroline’s underbaked Chocolate Almond Tart With Strawberry Compote.

How Chocolate Takes Bobby Back to His Childhood

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Stephen Davis Phillips
5 / 11

His Key Lime Pie From ‘Sweet, Sweet Revenge’

Guest co-hosts Michael Symon and Josh Capon entered the arena during Season 18 hoping for “Sweet, Sweet Revenge.” Although both of them specialize in savory food, just like Bobby, they arrived with secret weapons: Caroline Schiff (back to try to steal the trophy from Bobby), as well as cookbook author and executive pastry chef Clarice Lam. In battle blueberry, Caroline made the judges swoon with her Blueberry Cream Cheese Mousse Parfait. (Note to self: Study up on Caroline’s mousse method!)

This time, Caroline requested a Key Lime Pie clash. It was undeniable that Caroline’s Key Lime Pie With Tequila Raspberries tasted like a vacation. Still, Bobby’s traditional Key Lime Pie With Toasted Coconut won over the judges, who raved about the sweetened, coconut-spiked graham cracker crust.

Get Bobby's Key Lime-Coconut Pie Recipe

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Stephen Davis Phillips
6 / 11

Flourless Chocolate Cake From ‘Choc-O-Love’

With a title like “Choc-O-Love,” it tracks that Bobby tried to throw off his challengers with cocoa nibs as the first-round secret ingredient. World-renowned pastry chef David Lebovitz contested everything we thought we knew about cocoa with his Grapefruit Cocoa Nib Cocktail. Catering ace Ryan Scott shifted savory, presenting Cocoa Nib-Crusted Lamb.

David’s creativity and cocoa focus conquered, and the sweet world celebrity stuck to a similar theme as he took on Bobby: Flourless Chocolate Cake. Unfortunately, his choice of accenting that dish with salted caramel, candied almonds and a bourbon milkshake took the focus off the star. Bobby’s rendition (again, albeit a bit messy) delivered more focused chocolate flavor that was only made better by the topping of caramelized cocoa nibs and coconut crème anglaise. “It came down to the intensity of the chocolate in the cake,” one judge explained.

How Chocolate Takes Bobby Back to His Childhood

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Scott Gries. From: Chocolate Covered Clash
7 / 11

Chocolate Cream Pie From ‘Chocolate Covered Clash’

We hope Bobby likes chocolate, because it’s back at center stage for both rounds of Season 23’s “Chocolate Covered Clash.” Actor Drew Barrymore and Bobby’s Triple Threat Titan Michael Voltaggio team up to take down the show’s titular chef. Bobby threw pastry chefs DaVee Harned and Miriam Rieder Taylor a slow pitch with a Round 1 ingredient up their alley: chocolate hazelnut spread.

Little did Bobby know, DaVee’s winning Whiskey Chocolate Hazelnut Cake With Chocolate Hazelnut Mousse would be surprisingly great practice for the signature dish-off, which focused on Chocolate Cream Pie. The inventiveness of one of Bobby’s former colleagues, pastry chef Josephine Pacquing, helped inspire his unexpected, crust-topped combo of chocolate pudding, bourbon whipped cream and a chocolate hazelnut disc. The novelty allowed Bobby to inch above DaVee’s classic cracker crust with chocolate pudding, toasted meringue and caramel. “Visually, it looks like an unplanted flowerpot,” a judge said of Bobby’s dish. But once again, the flavor delighted.

Get the Recipe in Bobby's Cookbook

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Stephen Davis Phillips
8 / 11

Sticky Toffee Pudding From ‘A Sticky Situation’

More of The Kitchen crew was back in Season 25 to present Bobby with “A Sticky Situation.” They’re both Iron Chefs, too (Alex Guarnaschelli and Geoffrey Zakarian), so Bobby was guaranteed some stiff competition. For Round 1, the ICs waved in their pastry chefs, Erica Land and Jacqueline Joy Diño, who confidently entered the kitchen and immediately dove into Battle Brazil Nuts.

Erica’s twist on French toast garnered rave reviews, which allowed her to set the table for a Sticky Toffee Pudding showdown. At this point, Alex knew that sweets weren’t as much of a shoo-in as we all once believed. “Don't be fooled by the cute little, like, wolf in sheep's clothing stuff,” Alex warned Erika. “[Bobby] says he doesn't like this or he doesn't like to make it, but he makes it, and he pulls it off.”

Much to the disappointment of Alex, Geoffrey and Erica, Bobby did just that, blowing away the judges with his Sticky Toffee Pudding With Ginger Pecan Crumble and Crème Fraîche. “They thought they had me beat, but the proof was in the puddling,” Bobby teased.

Watch the Video

More photos after this Ad

9 / 11

Pumpkin Bundt Cake From ‘The Nightmare Before Pastry’

A couple of weeks before Halloween, guest co-hosts Katie and PieCaken inventor Zac Young aspired to read Bobby a bedtime story during Season 25. The title? “The Nightmare Before Pastry.” They invited cookie ace Michael McGowan and “Mr. Bake” Kareem Queeman to potentially haunt Bobby’s food-spiked dreams. But first, Bobby put these pros through the paces by asking them to highlight dragon fruit.

Kareem’s Dragon Fruit Shortcake swept the vote over Michael’s savory fruit tartare, setting up Pumpkin Bundt Cake. “Bundt cakes. Not an issue, well, until I start baking,” Bobby laughed. Kareem accented his creation with a tart cranberry coulis and a balanced orange cream cheese glaze. But the tame squash flavor wasn’t quite enough to overcome Bobby’s rich riff with ginger blackberry caramel and snickerdoodle crunch. Cookie, cake and caramel, all in one bite? Go ahead and give Bobby the medal.

Watch the Video

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Dawn Hoffmann
10 / 11

Bûche De Noël (Yule Log) From Holiday Throwdown ‘Room for Dessert’

The holiday festivities continue in “Room for Dessert,” one of the first-ever episodes of Beat Bobby Flay: Holiday Throwdown. Carla is back as co-host, and in this special series, the plot thickens with two rounds leading up to the Bobby battle, in an effort to find the strongest competitor possible to bring him down.

With Eggnog Ice Cream and a Panettone Cruller, Zac takes down both Damaris Phillips and Alex to win his way to choosing the final dessert du jour: Bûche de Noël. Zac invited Alex to join his team, which meant Damaris would be a second set of hands for Bobby. We were rooting for both teams and were blown away by how they each turned out three separate recipes. For Bobby and Damaris, Chocolate and Passionfruit Bûche de Noël, Berry Soldiers and Coconut Hot Chocolate. And for Zac and Alex, Chocolate and Hazelnut Bûche de Noël, Cocoa Nib Marshmallows and Holiday Chocolates. It wasn’t unanimous, but Team Bobby came out ahead. The clincher? Passionfruit, the judges agreed.

Watch the Episode on discovery+

More photos after this Ad

Photo: Stephen Davis Phillips
11 / 11

Tres Leches Cake From ‘Half-Baked’

Despite all of these victories, when guest co-hosts Duff Goldman and Amanda Freitag entered the arena rocking cupcake and pancake costumes for Season 42’s “Half Baked” episode, Bobby still insisted, “I like to eat [desserts]. I just don’t like to make them.”

Well, after Andy de la Cruz topped fellow pastry chef Yohann Le Bescond in a blueberry bake-off (dibs on any extra of Andy’s blueberry crisp, please!), the deck was stacked for a delicious second round. And it’s all about Tres Leches Cake, a treat that Andy adores sharing with his wife.

“Tres leches cake is generally cake sponge soaked in whole milk, sweetened condensed milk and evaporated milk,” Duff explained. Andy likes sharing a slice with his beloved, but he was determined to not share the gold medal with Bobby. So, Andy pushed the round to the final second to perfect his Berry Tres Leches Cake With Strawberry Mousse and Lace Tuile. Showy, sure, and tasty, too. But Bobby’s tropical Coquito Tres Leches Cake With Coconut Whipped Cream had more “oomph,” the judges conceded.

Watch the Episode on discovery+

Next Up

We Recommend