How to Choose a Healthy Yogurt

These days, you can’t miss the yogurt aisle. Markets now have 2, 3 or more cases designated to this creamy delight. But with so many choices, it’s easy to become overwhelmed and confused on which is healthiest.


Blueberry yogurt in a glass

Photo by: Nanisimova


These days, you can't miss the yogurt aisle. Markets now have two, three or more cases designated to this creamy delight. But with so many choices, it's easy to become overwhelmed and confused on which is healthiest.

Added vs. Natural Sugar

Before eyeballing any label, understand that you'll find sugar in each any yogurt you pick up. Yogurt has natural sugar (called lactose) and unless it's a plain variety it will also have sugar added for sweetness.  The nutrition facts combine both the natural and added sugar under "sugars." The only way to know if any sugar was added is to look at the ingredients list.

To keep in line with the recommendations from The American Heart Association, women should limit their sugar to no more than 6 teaspoons per day (or 100 calories' worth) while men should  eat a max of 9 teaspoons of sugar per day (or 150 calories). This means capping sugar to no more than 20 grams per serving, which would be about 2 teaspoons of added sugar.

Some brands use sugar substitutes instead of added sugar. This will help lower the total sugar amount--remember, you will still be getting natural sugar from the yogurt. I tend to shy away from those varieties and rather purchase a plain yogurt and flavor it myself with a touch of natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup.


These good bacteria are found in most yogurts help keep your digestive tract in working order. You can find the actual bacteria names under the ingredient list—look for words like L. acidophilus, L. casei, B. bifidum and B. Longum.

Calcium & Vitamin

Important for healthy bones, calcium and vitamin D are two important nutrients found in yogurt. Although calcium is naturally found in dairy foods, vitamin D is added. The amounts of these important nutrients vary depending on the brand and fat content (low fat, full fat or nonfat) so be sure to read the label.


The USDA’s Dietary Guidelines recommends choosing a low-fat or nonfat yogurt. Some nonfat yogurts contain artificial sweeteners, though nowadays you can find brands that use nonfat milk. Full-fat yogurts are also found on the market, but also contain more saturated fat and cholesterol. Choose low-fat or nonfat whenever possible.

Other Ingredients

Many yogurts contain fillers, stabilizers, and thickeners. The only way to tell is to carefully read through the ingredient list. If there are too many words you can't pronounce, just skip it.

Greek Yogurt

If you haven't noticed, half the yogurt aisle consists of Greek (or strained) yogurt. If you're looking for less sugar, Greek may be the way to go since some of the sugar is lost during the straining process. Greek yogurt also has less lactose per serving, making it a more lactose-intolerant friendly food. Just like traditional yogurt, choose low or nonfat Greek yogurt varieties with no more than 20 grams of sugar per serving.

TELL US: What do you look for in your yogurt?

Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, is a registered dietitian and consultant who specializes in food safety and culinary nutrition. See Toby's full bio »

Next Up

How to Choose the Best Water Filter for You

Everything you want to know about filtering your drinking water.

Is Cereal Healthy?

Research shows people who eat cereal for breakfast may eat more underconsumed nutrients than those who eat other breakfast foods.

Is Subway Healthy?

Choices are key at this sandwich chain.

Is Pasta Healthy?

Why you can (and should!) embrace pasta as part of a healthful diet, according to a dietitian.

Is Falafel Healthy?

This classic dish is loaded with fiber- and protein-packed chickpeas, but is it good for you?

Is Tofu Healthy?

Tofu isn't just for vegans or healthy eaters. Here's why tofu should be a part of any healthy diet plan.

Is Air Frying Healthy?

The biggest myth about air fryer chicken nuggets, busted.

Is Skim Milk Healthy?

Skim milk is lower in fat and calories than other milk varieties, but does that make it better for you? A dietitian weighs in.

12 Healthy Lemon Recipes

Do you love lemon? Try these 12 healthy lemony recipes.

Are Veggie Straws Healthy?

Some say this popular snack food counts toward your daily recommended vegetables. Here's what a dietitian has to say.