Cute or Gross? Couple Eats Same Piece of Wedding Cake Every Year for Five Decades

Our nutrition expert says she would not recommend it.

Selective focus


Selective focus

Photo by: Picsale ©Picsale

Picsale, Picsale

Food and the celebration of life’s milestones go together like, say, a couple that has been married for half a century. But it is arguably possible to take that connection a tad too far.

Take, for example, the case of Anne and David Cowburn, Pennsylvania teachers who have been married for 49 years … and counting. Every year on their wedding anniversary – July 18, if you’d like to send a gift (perhaps a fresh baked good?) – the Cowburns celebrate by eating a bite of their original wedding cake, baked in 1970, according to recent press reports.

The ancient slice of vanilla cake, which they have stored in their freezer, wrapped in plastic wrap and baggies, for well nigh half a century, originally measured about four by five inches, according to the New York Post, but by now after years of the Cowburns cutting away slivers to "gently" feed each other — it has dwindled significantly in size, Today reports.

It has also dwindled significantly in flavor. David Cowburn has described the cake as currently tasting like "something between cardboard or lighter fluid," adding, "I don't remember when it tasted good." Anne noted that the cake flavor hung in there for about 10 years, albeit a bit "freezer burned" (having survived several house moves). Now, however, "it doesn’t really taste like anything, just kind of chemical-ly," she told Today.

The Cowburns say the cake is not moldy and has not ever made either one of them sick. They consider the tradition "fun" and "romantic."

It probably goes without saying that others consider it rather gross.

"Ewwww!" says Toby Amidor, MS, RD, CDN, FAND, award-winning nutrition expert and Wall Street Journal best selling author of The Healthy Meal Prep Cookbook.

While Amidor says she is happy the Cowburns have been able to enjoy their cake and not get sick, she definitely would not recommend eating such dramatically outdated food.

"Although this couple was able to minimize the threat from pathogenic microorganisms, who is to say that someone else wouldn't?" she tells FN Dish. "The freezer is meant as a temporary storage unit for food, and microorganisms can still grow — just very slowly — on frozen foods especially when in there for many years."

Amidor says a better, tastier tradition for the Cowburns — and others — might be recreating their original wedding cake every year so they can enjoy something delicious "instead of dining on a chemical-tasting crumb."

In fact, for their 50th wedding anniversary, the couple is reportedly hoping to have the remaining original cake crumbs baked into a new cake by the original baker.

Now that will be something to celebrate.

Photo: iStock

Related Links:

Next Up

5 Inexpensive Kitchen Tools I Replace Every Year

Keep your kitchen in tiptop shape with a few new essentials.

This Couple Served Pizza Cake at Their Wedding

Traditional wedding cakes can be things of true, tiered beauty, but for one Miami couple, pizza was better.

Meredith Vieira Has Reused the Same Disposable Cutlery for Decades

And if she invites you to a kids birthday party, beware of the paper plates.

The Friends Cast Ate the Same Lunch Every … Single … Day

It was a Cobb salad that 'wasn’t really a Cobb salad.'

5 Cute, Kid-Friendly Pumpkin Decorating Ideas

These no-carve pumpkin ideas are great for all ages.

Best 5 New Year's Recipes

Check out Food Network's top-five recipes for New Year's entertaining, a collection of party-ready dishes from your favorite Food Network chefs.

Piece of Cake Summer Party

Summer is winding down, but it's not too late to throw one more outdoor party and go out with a bang! We're getting one last taste of summer with these fun, new party ideas. The Kitchen and party planner Mary Giuliani teamed up to make a memorable summer party with "snacktivities" for all ages.

Piece of Cake Summer Party

Throw a great summer party with our easy tips for pleasing a crowd. We'll show you how to upgrade your favorite dishes and let your guests customize their cocktails with these new ideas for food, drinks and more!

What's New