Costco’s Cult-Favorite Half-Sheet Cakes May Be No More

Are the big, rectangular cakes ever going to make a comeback?

June 29, 2020

526247176

Photo by: Francis Dean/Getty

Francis Dean/Getty

It’s a birthday tradition in my house: the Costco half-sheet cake. We also enjoy the massive, majorly delicious cakes for graduations, holiday parties and occasionally, just when the mood strikes. Leave it to buttercream to brighten a bad day.

But time moves on, things change and some traditions require updating. The Costco half-sheet cake — rectangular and for so long reliably available — is apparently one of those traditions. The members-only warehouse chain has announced on Facebook that half-sheet cakes “are currently not available to order or customize” at U.S. store bakeries. What’s more, this is apparently the new normal: The company has said it has “no immediate plans” to reintroduce the half-sheet cakes.

Instead, Costco is now offering a 10-inch round cake — available in both vanilla and chocolate, judging from an accompanying video posted on Facebook — for people in need of a substitute to mark a special occasion.

The news of the cake’s sudden, shocking disappearance sparked an outpouring of love for the cakes and despair (and yes, a great deal of denial) when confronted with the concept that they may never come back.

“PLLEEEEEEEEEASSE bring back the half sheet cakes!! Best cakes ever! Worth the price of membership on its own! Birthdays are disappointing without one!!” pleaded one commenter.

“The sheet cake was the main reason I even got a membership!” wrote another.

“We LOVED the old chocolate cake, bring it back!!!” begged a third.

Meanwhile, one commenter had the presence of mind to calmly request an explanation.

“Why are sheet cakes not available?” she inquired.

Costco responded: “To help limit personal contact and create more space for social distancing, Costco has reduced service in some departments. At this time, we are not making sheet cakes for special order. Thank you for understanding.”

Related Links:

Next Up

More Frozen Strawberries Recalled from Walmart, Costco and H-E-B

Double check your freezers — the latest recall is for packages potentially contaminated with hepatitis A.

This Costco-Themed Birthday Cake Is So Dang Cute

A self-taught cake artist’s latest creation is going viral on TikTok.

Why Is There No More Mexican Pizza at Taco Bell?

Demand for the returning item was more than seven times than when it was last on the menu.

The Most Instagrammed Chain Restaurant May Surprise You

Based on hashtags alone, one nationwide eatery is the most likely to make your grid.

The Key Food Moments You May Have Missed in The Last of Us

Everyone picked up on the cookies and cake, right?

Instacart Reveals America’s Favorite Hot Sauce

This bottle is the top sauce in a staggering 31 states.

Mexican Pizza Is Coming Back to Taco Bell Menus on May 19

After 17 long months, the wait is finally over!

Your Chipotle Bowl or Salad May Soon Be Made by a Robot

The chain is testing a new automated process to help fulfill digital orders.

This Is Not a Drill: McDonald’s Cult-Favorite Szechuan Sauce Returns March 31

The coveted sauce will only be available to order on the McDonald’s app.

This TikToker Is Going Viral for Ripping an Apple In Half with His Bare Hands

The adorable teacher breaks it down step by step, so we can all learn this act of sorcery.

What's New