How to Make a Giant Conversation Heart Cake for Valentine's Day

Sharing the love has never been cuter!

Related To:

Not everyone is a fan of conversation hearts: In a recent poll, more than two-thirds of Food Network fans said they don’t eat them. But this heart is different — it’s a giant cake! To create the supersize sweet, Food Network Magazine turned two cakes into a heart shape, then covered the whole thing in a homemade marshmallow fondant. For the message, you just need food coloring...and something sweet to say!

Get the Recipe: Conversation Heart Cake

Step One:

Preheat the oven to 350 F. Coat a 9-inch round and a 9-inch square cake pan
(2 inches deep) with cooking spray. Prepare the cake mixes as directed; divide between the pans. Bake until a toothpick comes out clean, 30 to 35 minutes.

Step Two:

Let the cakes cool, then remove from the pans. Trim the tops of the cakes with a long serrated knife to make them level. Cut the round cake in half as shown.

Step Three:

Working on a cake board (you can cut the board into a heart shape to fit the cake) or a cutting board, position the 2 half circles of cake against 2 sides of the square cake to make a heart.

Step Four:

Cover the cake with the white frosting, using the frosting to fill in any gaps between the cakes.

Step Five:

Combine the marshmallows and water in a large microwave-safe bowl. Microwave, stirring with a rubber spatula, until melted and smooth, 1 to 2 minutes. Add the green food coloring and stir until smooth.

Step Six:

Transfer the marshmallow mixture to a stand mixer. Gradually add all but 1/2 cup of the confectioners’ sugar and beat until combined. Beat in the butter.

Step Seven:

Scrape the marshmallow fondant onto a sheet of parchment and knead in confectioners’ sugar until it’s no longer sticky. Dust the parchment with more sugar; roll out the fondant until it’s large enough to cover the cake, at least 13 by 16 inches.

Step Eight:

Carefully flip the parchment and fondant onto the cake; peel off the parchment. Gently press the fondant against the sides of the cake and smooth with your hands; trim the excess. Brush off the extra sugar.

Step Nine:

Use the wide end of a chopstick to press letters into the fondant (it’s best to do this before the fondant dries out). Use a small brush to paint hot pink or red food coloring in the letter indentations.


All photos by Yunhee Kim.

Text taken from Food Network Magazine.

Related Links:

Next Up

16 Food Gifts You Can Ship for Valentine’s Day

Whether you're in a long-distance relationship or want to send your best friends some sweet treats, these presents are perfect for Valentine's Day gifting.

20 Best Food Gifts for Valentine's Day

From aromatic ice cream to charcuterie bouquets, these tasty treats are guaranteed to make your sweetheart swoon.

22 Adorable Valentine’s Day Gifts for Kids

We found cute, whimsical and *actually cool* gifts kids of all ages will love.

11 Best Chocolate Boxes for Valentine's Day

We included something for Galentine's, candy lovers and more!

23 Valentine's Day Gifts Your Friends Will Love

Because your best friends deserve something sweet, too!

22 Valentine’s Day Gifts for Men Who Love Food

The best gifts for the guy who loves to eat and drink.

The Best Wines for Valentine's Day, According to a Sommelier

Whether you're celebrating a major relationship milestone or a Galentine's Day, these are the best wines for the occasion.

10 Valentine’s Day Food Bouquets That Are Way Better Than Flowers

After all, the way to the heart is through the stomach!

5 Nontraditional Valentine's Day Dining Ideas: No Reservations Required!

Maybe a romantic dinner just means splurging (calorically) on a favorite comfort food together.

5 Tips to Understanding Bubbly

Resist saving bubbly just for birthdays and ball drops and instead enjoy it throughout dinner. Part and parcel of upping your BCQ (Bubbly Consumption Quotient) is mastering these simple points.

Latest Stories