Reddit Is Discussing the Foods People Intentionally Cook Wrong and The Answers Are Wild

"I just put oats in a cup and eat them with a spoon."

June 01, 2021


Photo by: Nora Carol Photography/Getty

Nora Carol Photography/Getty

Reddit users have discussed everything from freezing guacamole to what foods work best with some of Trader Joes’ most popular seasoning blends, but a recent topic of conversation is a bit more obscure.

About three weeks ago, someone with the username ThymeandGarlic wanted to know what foods, if any, people purposefully prepare incorrectly. The user got the ball rolling by explaining that they make scrambled eggs differently than most. “I love to over cook them, and can’t eat them when they’re made properly. I think it’s because scrambled eggs were the first meal I ever made as a kid, and years of conditioning have caused me to like them the ‘wrong’ way,” ThymeandGarlic wrote. “Am I a maniac or do other people do this with other foods?”

Not surprisingly, thousands of other Reddit users were quick to chime in, and many of them had some pretty wild cooking and eating habits. For example, a user by the name of KantalopeKat explained that instead of eating cooked oats, she consumes them raw as a snack.

“[I] just put them in a cup and eat them with a spoon,” she wrote. “My husband always asks if I would like a feed bag...haha!”

Apparently KantalopeKat isn’t alone in her love of uncooked oats. Another user, Dwight_Schnood, replied that their three-year-old son also loves to eat the raw grains. “He started eating it whilst feeding ducks. Now he sits down at dinner and asks for bird food,” Dwight_Schnood wrote.

Believe it or not, oats aren’t the only breakfast food that Reddit users purposefully prepare wrong. As it turns out, many people also take some culinary liberties when it comes to cooking pancakes.

“My grandpa is a terrible cook so when he makes pancakes they’re always burned on the outside and basically raw batter on the inside, but they taste so good like that,” a user named belleandblue wrote. “He always asks: ‘How are they? Are they fully cooked?’ and we all just say yes because we purposely want him to keep making them like that.”

Apparently undercooking pancakes on purpose is a bit of a trend. Another user commented that their spouse was accidentally making pancakes with a raw center that their kids ended up loving, while a third user said they also like it when their pancakes are underdone. “Something about the raw batter made it feel like a cream filled pancake I guess.”

And while professional chefs are typically very careful not to under- or over-season their food, there’s a whole contingent of Reddit users who prefer to be heavy-handed with the black pepper. “If I’m cooking for just myself, I go very heavy on the pepper. Especially on red meat and soups,” one user wrote.

Another explained: “You should see my Bloody Mary peppering.”

As a third user noted, there really are no limits to the amount of black pepper you can use while cooking. “I’ve never actually had any food with too much black pepper,” they declared. And I’ve tried.”

Related Content:

Next Up

Reddit Resurfaces Queen Elizabeth’s Pancake Recipe

The Queen shared 'Drop Scones' with President Eisenhower in 1960.

Is Heinz’s Holiday Dinner in A Can the Answer to Our Problems?

Between supermarket inflation and hours of prep work, people are looking to a curious canned soup to get their Christmas dinner fill.

This Retro Recipe for 'Surprise Burgers' Is Going Viral on Reddit: Here’s How to Make Them

A Food Network recipe developer offers tips on how to make the burgers tastier.

TikTok Is Mesmerized By People Peeling Raw, Uncooked Eggs

It’s a slow, meticulous process, and once you start watching, it’s hard to look away.

Pepsi Releases ‘Softer Than a Soft Drink’ Cola For People Who Don’t Like Heavy Carbonation

Nitro Pepsi boasts smaller bubbles, a creamier consistency and a frothy, foamy head.

Instacart Is Offering a High-Tech Alternative to Traditional Food Drives

Its new Community Carts feature also allows you to optimize your giving to meet local needs.

Ronzoni Pastina Is Being Discontinued, and People Are In Shambles

The outrage over the decision is as big as the star-shaped pasta variety is small.

The Key Food Moments You May Have Missed in The Last of Us

Everyone picked up on the cookies and cake, right?

Now There’s Phoodle – A Food-Themed Wordle-Like Game

Five-letter word solutions are 'ingredients,' 'appliances' and 'famous chefs.'

Your Favorite Fast Food Dessert Is Now a Cereal

Get the taste of a Wendy's Frosty without having to go to the drive-thru.


Guy's Ranch Kitchen

8:30am | 7:30c

Guy's Ranch Kitchen

9:30am | 8:30c


10am | 9c


11am | 10c


12pm | 11c


1pm | 12c


2pm | 1c


3pm | 2c


4pm | 3c


5pm | 4c


6pm | 5c


7pm | 6c


8pm | 7c
On Tonight
On Tonight

Tournament of Champions

10pm | 9c


3am | 2c

What's New