Where To Get Jack-O’-Lantern Pizzas This Halloween

Here are a few pizza chains offering pumpkin-shaped pies with pepperoni smiles.

Updated on October 24, 2023
Follow Amy on:

Photo by: Photo courtesy of Papa Johns

Photo courtesy of Papa Johns

Is a jack-o’-lantern-shaped pizza a trick, a treat or both? Discuss. Or better yet, just dig into one — grab a slice and take a bite.

This Halloween, several pizza chains are offering party-perfect, pumpkin-shaped pies — topped with cheese and, often, a cheesy grin. Here are a few jack-o’-lantern pizza deals that will definitely deliver a smile. (Cute or creepy — you be the judge.)

Photo by: Photo courtesy of Chuck E. Cheese

Photo courtesy of Chuck E. Cheese

Aldi: The supermarket chain is bringing back its pumpkin- and ghost-shaped frozen pizzas for 2023. Mama Cozzi’s Pizza Kitchen Halloween Pumpkin or Ghost Pizza on October 4. Priced at $4.99, these pizzas are seasonal Aldi Finds and tend to go fast.

Casey’s: The Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza at Casey’s is served unsliced, made from its from-scratch dough, and topped with marinara, mozzarella and a face made with pepperoni and black olives. It’s available for a limited time for delivery or pickup and offers 2x Points for Casey’s rewards members.

Chuck E. Cheese: As part of its fourth annual Halloween Boo-tacular celebration, the family-friendly dining and entertainment chain is bringing back its Pumpkin Pepperoni Pizza this year. The seasonally appropriate pizza costs around $24, and is available individually for dine-in, delivery or carryout — or as part of a Boo-tacular Family Pack (two one-topping pizzas, slime cookie, goody bag, 250 e-tickets and activity sheet, for $49.99). Other items on Chuck E. Cheese’s special Halloween menu include a Creepy Cupcake, a Slime Cookie and Dippin’ Dots Eye Scream, featuring edible slime, gummy worms and a candy eyeball. While the pizza features cheese, pepperoni and two black olives, the brand promises that “there’s no actual pumpkin on this pizza.” Chuck E. Cheese’s Halloween celebration from October 2 to 31 at all locations in the U.S. and Canada includes free candy for the kids, free e-tickets for costume-wearers and at least 30 minutes of free play time.

Papa Johns: Papa Johns’ Jack-O’-Lantern pizza, which the chain calls its “spookiest pie ever,” is returning again this year. As in years past, the large, pumpkin-shaped pie is served unsliced and features a thin crust topped with vine-ripened-tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni and black olives. It’s made to pair with Papa Johns’ lineup of sides and can be ordered for $10.99 for a limited time, from October 23 through October 31.

Papa Murphy’s: Promising to be a “monster hit” again this year, the Jack-O Pizza is back at Papa Murphy’s for the month of October — and only for the month of October. Jack-o’-lantern-shaped, smiling and topped with pepperoni, the Jack-O Pizza, which you bake yourself, can be ordered online for pickup or delivery, an “order today, bake tomorrow” option that seems perfect for an easy post-trick-or-treating meal.

Peter Piper Pizza: Peter Piper Pizza wants to help you get into the Halloween spirit with its “Spooky Special,” a deal that consists of a large one-topping Jack-o’-Lantern pizza (cheese, pepperoni, olive eyes) and a Halloween crunch dessert for $21.99. The chain is also offering an Orange Scream Halloween ICEE starting at $3.49.

Related Content:

Next Up

12 Must-Have Pumpkin Carving Tools on Amazon for Creating the Perfect Jack-o'-Lantern

These tools are all you need to create a classic Halloween decoration.

Reese’s Makes Trick-or-Treat Bag That Helps You Hide Your Favorite Candy

The unassuming jack-o-lantern bag comes complete with a secret compartment.

Oh, My Gourd!

Usher in Halloween with 2 super-easy jack-o'-lantern ideas that require little to no carving. Oh, my gourd, it's pumpkin time!

Guacamole Pumpkin

The Kitchen has the ultimate gross-out presentation idea for your next Halloween table. Don't just serve guacamole. Serve it in a sick Guacamole Jack-o'-Lantern!

You Can Now Get Jack Daniel’s & Coca-Cola In a Can

It’s easier than ever to drink the classic bar combo.

31 Days of Pumpkins

Whether it’s for dinner, dessert or carving Jack-o-lanterns, nothing says fall quite like orange pumpkins. We’ve got pumpkin ideas for every day of the month.

10 Gadgets to Get Your Kitchen Ready for Halloween

Vampires, monsters and more make for cute and creepy additions to your kitchen cabinets for Halloween.

Where To Get Tyson’s Too-cute Halloween Nuggets

Snatch these up for a scary good pre-trick-or-treating meal.

Where To Get Heart-Shaped Pizzas for Valentine’s Day 2024

Pizza is a great way to say 'I Love You' — or ‘Goodbye?’

On TV

BBQ Brawl

6am | 5c

BBQ Brawl

7am | 6c

Chopped

8am | 7c

Chopped

9am | 8c

Chopped

10am | 9c

Chopped

11am | 10c

Beat Bobby Flay

3:30pm | 2:30c

Beat Bobby Flay

4:30pm | 3:30c

Beat Bobby Flay

5:30pm | 4:30c

Beat Bobby Flay

6:30pm | 5:30c

Beat Bobby Flay

7:30pm | 6:30c
On Tonight
On Tonight
9pm | 8c
10pm | 9c
11pm | 10c
12am | 11c
1am | 12c
2am | 1c

Beat Bobby Flay

4:30am | 3:30c

What's New