Which is Healthier, a Tuna or a Turkey Sandwich?

Two popular brown-bag lunch items are tuna salad sandwich and turkey sandwiches. These bad boys are going head-to-head for the title of healthiest sandwich.
turkey and tuna
Brown Bag Challenge

We’re teaming up with fellow food bloggers to host a Brown-Bag Challenge, a month-long initiative to eat consciously and save money by packing a lunch each weekday instead of eating out. Join us here and share what you're eating on Facebook and Twitter with the hashtag #brownbag.

Healthy Eats' Brown-Bag Challenge has folks from around the country packing their lunches this month. Two popular brown bag items have been tuna salad sandwich and turkey sandwiches. These bad boys are going head-to-head for the title of healthiest sandwich.

Tuna Salad Sandwich

Pros:

Three ounces of canned tuna in water contains 108 calories and 20 grams of protein. It provides 5 percent of your daily iron needs, a multitude of energy boosting B-vitamins and 80% of your daily recommended amount of selenium. Tuna is also plentiful in omega-3 fat, which is important for heart health, growth and brain function. For the sandwich, using whole grain bread can up your daily dose of fiber as can piling up on the veggies.

Cons:

The FDA suggests limiting fish consumption to twice a week to moderate the amount of mercury we take in. Certain varieties of canned tuna (i.e. albacore) are higher in mercury than others. Knowing which variety of tuna to choose is important.  Three ounces of canned tuna contains 320 milligrams of sodium, which is 13 percent of the daily recommended amount.

Tuna is a healthy food. But when folks make tuna salad, they tend to go overboard on the mayo adding tons of extra calories and fat. One cup of mayo has a whopping 1440 calories, 160 grams fat, and 24 grams saturated fat. It’ll also tack on almost 50 percent of your daily recommended amount of sodium.

Healthy Tuna Sandwich Tips:
  • Keep mayo in check. Use 1 tablespoon per person when making your tuna salad.
  • Choose the right can of tuna—chunk light in water contains less mercury than albacore.
  • 2-3 ounces of tuna is just the right portion. Pile slices of tomato, onion and lettuce to bulk up your sandwich.
  • Choose whole grain bread like whole-wheat or rye.
  • Get more tips on how to lighten up your tuna salad.
Turkey Sandwich

Pros:

Turkey is low in fat and lower in calories than many other meats. Three ounces has about 90 calories and three grams of fat. It provides a variety of B-vitamins and the antioxidant selenium.

Cons:

Deli meats are notorious for two not-so-healthy things: nitrites and sodium. Nitrites are added to deli meats to keep their color bright and help prevent bacteria growth. The problem is that nitrites have been linked to various types of cancer, especially in children and pregnant women. Deli meats also contain high amounts of sodium. Three ounces (a typical serving of deli meat) contains 42 percent of your daily recommended amount of sodium.

This relatively healthy sandwich can easily be sabotaged by piles of meat and gobs of mayo. Like to have a turkey sandwich made at the deli? They tend to pile on almost double that amount of deli meat (and sodium). Tablespoons of mayo can also add many unnecessary calories and fat to your sandwich.

Another food safety concern that has been linked to deli meat is the bacteria Listeria monocytogenes. This bacteria affects the very young and old and can cause a pregnant woman to have a miscarriage during their third trimester (scary stuff!). To prevent Listeria, it's important to buy small amounts of deli meat at a time and use within 2 to 3 days. Also, don't let it hang out on the countertop during a meal, but rather take what you need and refrigerate the rest immediately. Pregnant women are advised to avoid deli meat altogether.

Healthy Turkey Sandwich Tips:
  • Look for reduced-sodium turkey at your deli counter.
  • Make turkey sandwiches with the appropriate portion of deli meat.
  • Pile on the veggies for extra bulk.
  • Instead of mayo, use mustard or hummus on your turkey sandwich.
  • Choose whole grain bread like whole wheat or rye.
  • Check out more tips to making smarter choices at the deli counter.
  • Be sure to discard deli meat after several days—they don’t last very long in the fridge.
YOU VOTE: Who’s the winner? The tuna salad sandwich or turkey sandwich?

Next Up

Which Is Healthier: Turkey Burger or Beef Burger?

Beef burgers get a bad rap, but turkey burgers can cook up dry and bland. Here's what to know about choosing the best burger at your next cookout.

Are Nuts or Seeds Healthier?

When it comes to salad toppers, butters or snacks, here's how the nutrition of nuts and seeds compare.

7 Healthier Desserts for Passover

These homemade Passover desserts are a sweet (and healthy) way to end the meal.

Is Drinking Hot Water Healthier?

We break down whether the temperature of your drinking water matters.

Which Is Better: Smoothies or Juices?

Both are made of fruits and vegetables, but they're not created equal.

Which Is Better: Spinning or Rowing?

Experts weigh in on which exercise will benefit you the most.

How to Make Egg Salad Healthier

This sandwich staple can be high in fat, cholesterol and calories, but with a few simple tweaks it can be made more nutritious.

How Nutritionists Make Nostalgic Recipes Healthier

Dietitians love comfort food, too. Here’s how they reimagine their favorites into healthier recipes.

Walking or Running: Which Is Better Exercise?

We break down the benefits of both, so you can decide which is right for you.

Which Restaurants Are Open On Christmas Day?

Take a breather after all that holiday cooking.