How to Stay Paleo on Thanksgiving

Think of it as Hunter-Gatherersgiving.

Related To:

Eat like your ancestors — that's the basic principle of the paleo diet. How, though, does that translate when you'd like to stay paleo for Thanksgiving? Here's a quick present-day primer on how to eat like it's 10,000 years ago, and how to stock your Thanksgiving paleo pantry.

What is the paleo diet? There was no modern agriculture during the Paleolithic period. Accordingly, adhering to the paleo diet today means avoiding processed foods (including refined sugars, grains and dairy) and loading up on vegetables, (some) fruit, nuts, seeds, herbs, spices, healthy fats and meat from ethically raised animals.

What are the supposed health benefits? Paleo advocates claim that the diet cuts out foods that can contribute to weight gain, heart disease and diabetes. It can be rich in foods high in soluble fiber, antioxidants, phytochemicals, heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids and monounsaturated fats — all of which hopefully contribute to better health.

What's out? Foods that are highly processed: white or whole-grain flour, processed sugar (think high-fructose corn syrup), grains, pulses (lentils), legumes (beans and even peanuts), artificial sweeteners and overly salted food.

What's in? Grass-fed beef and organic, pasture-raised poultry, wild-caught fish and seafood, organic eggs, healthy fats (olive and avocado), indulgent fats (ghee, grass-fed butter, duck fat), dark leafy greens, sweet potatoes, butternut squash, fruits* (apples, berries, citrus, melon, peaches, plums), nuts, seeds, herbs, spices and sea salt.

*Bananas are controversial — some say yes, while others say no.

Thanksgiving paleo pantry

Go gather these at your local supermarket (hunting not required):

Organic, pasture-raised turkey or chicken

Avocado, olive and/or walnut oils

Grass-fed butter

Duck fat

Chicken liver

Wild-caught salmon

Organic eggs

Fruits: apples, berries, citrus fruits

Vegetables: broccoli, Brussels sprouts, butternut squash, cabbage, cauliflower, collard greens, spinach, sweet potatoes

Nuts: any of your favorites

Seeds: any of your favorites

Fresh herbs

Dried spices

Sea salt

Note that there are other seasonal paleo-approved fruits and vegetables; the ones listed here are the most-Thanksgiving-friendly.

Thanksgiving menu ideas

Turkey: Organic and pasture raised. No stuffing (sorry), and avoid brining (because of the sugar and salt). If you plan to rub it down with butter, make sure the butter was made with milk from grass-fed cows.

Salmon: Try a new main-course tradition, or go "surf and turf" and serve salmon alongside your bird. Try a Simple Lemon-Herb Roasted Salmon or a showstopping whole roasted side of salmon with walnut-pepper relish (skip the honey).

Liver: Serve chopped liver as an appetizer with fresh veggies for dipping and spreading.

Eggs: These prosciutto and egg cups would be great next to a mountain of salad.

Salad: Load your salad with toasted nuts, apple and citrus, and toss with a simple dressing of oil and lemon juice. Season to taste with sea salt.

Broccoli: Make simple sauteed broccoli with a pinch of heat, or savor the browned bits of roasted broccoli.

Brussels sprouts: Let garlic, cumin and cilantro jazz up your Brussels sprout dish, or make a raw side dish tossed with toasted pecans and lemon.

Butternut squash: Make this dairy-free soup as a first course, or cut down on cooking time with this grated skillet butternut squash side dish.

Cabbage: Instead of making coleslaw, roast cabbage in duck fat; it's crispy, tender and will probably be the crowd favorite (no, seriously). You can also roast cabbage with butter and thyme for a vegetarian version.

Cauliflower: Try a dairy-free Cauliflower Mash with fried sage and forget about potatoes. Or roast cauliflower with tomatoes and finish with a sprinkle of fresh parsley.

Collard greens: Hearty and with a pleasant leathery chew, this collard green recipe is super-simple.

Spinach: The Georgian (as in the country, not the state) combo of walnuts, cilantro, tarragon and dill is dazzling in a vegetarian and paleo-friendly Spinach-Walnut Pate.

Sweet potatoes: Top Sweet Potato Lyonnaise with chopped pecans, or put your knife skills to the test and make Hasselback Sweet Potatoes (skip the yogurt sauce).

Dessert: Is not really a big paleo thing — all those potential refined sugars. But for the rogue sweet tooth, here are a few ideas:

- Put out platters of fresh, seasonal fruit and nuts after dinner.

- Section citrus fruits like blood and navel oranges, clementines and pink, ruby and white grapefruit— or peel and slice them into rounds and toss with the seeds scraped from fresh vanilla beans or a splash of pure vanilla extract.

- Cut apples into thick slices (scoop out the core with a melon baller), slather each piece with your favorite nut or seed butter, and sprinkle with sunflower and chia seeds.

- Toss fresh berries with chopped fresh mint and the smallest pinch of dried culinary lavender.

- Make a fresh fruit salad and top with a grating of fresh nutmeg right before serving.

- If you consider bananas paleo appropriate, then go for a magical 1-ingredient (plus vanilla) banana ice cream (aka nice cream) — there's no added sugar. It can be whipped up in a food processor and frozen a couple of days ahead.

Related Stories:

Next Up

How to Prep for a Thanksgiving Potluck

Don't fret over the big feast.

Chill Out with These Cold Thanksgiving Sides

They'll get a warm reception from your guests.

How to Make Thanksgiving with As Little Prep As Possible

No, you don't need to plan for days to make this meal — especially if you're feeding a smaller crowd.

What to Bring to Friendsgiving

You don't need to spend a ton of money to contribute something thoughtful.

The Ridiculously Easy Recipe I Make Every Year for Friendsgiving

Because your friends deserve more than a bag of chips.

How to Host Thanksgiving Without Turning Your Kitchen Into a Total Mess

Here are 12 helpful tips to contain the mess and ease the stress.

8 Thanksgiving Meatloaf Recipes to Make This Year

Turkey meatloaf is an inexpensive alternative to roasting a whole bird.

How to Make Mashed Potatoes Step-By-Step

Master the perfect mashed potatoes with these easy-to-follow tips.

Latest Stories