What's the Difference Between a Hotdish and a Casserole? Andrew Zimmern Schools Us
Plus, learn his secrets for one of the chef’s all-time favorite comfort food casseroles.
Eric Wolfinger / The Blue Food Cookbook: Delicious Seafood Recipes for a Sustainable Future, by Andrew Zimmern and Barton Seaver. Copyright © 2025. Reprinted with permission from Harvest, an imprint of William Morrow.
Celebrities, they’re just like us! James Beard Award-winning chef Andrew Zimmern isn’t too proud to admit that he adores a classic tuna noodle casserole.
Some might try to claim that “casserole season” commences during fall and winter. We get it: The traditional Thanksgiving menu does include many MVPs (ahem, green bean casserole and sweet potato casserole!), and cozy, one-pan recipes are ideal for hibernation season.
But here at Food Network, we adore this culinary category so much that we refuse to put limits on it. Any day can be a casserole day if you declare it so. Whenever you choose to whip one up, you have an award-winning chef who will proudly act as your advocate, cheering you on each step of the way. According to Andrew Zimmern, chef and host of Pitmasters, “In the Midwest, where I live, casseroles and hotdishes are a religion in the kitchen.”
The first commandment of this religion? Thou shalt make and share them often. The second? Honor the difference between hotdish and casserole.
Both are easy, inexpensive and ideal for feeding a large crowd, Andrew admitted. But the 34-year Minnesota resident took to the pages of his The Blue Food Cookbook: Delicious Seafood Recipes for a Sustainable Future (which he co-wrote with his pal Barton Seaver in collaboration with ocean food advocacy nonprofit Fed by Blue) to clarify the distinct difference between the two. “Casseroles are mixed and baked. Hotdishes are layered,” Andrew explained.
Food historians believe that casseroles date back to the 13th century, when Europeans reportedly crafted dishes that are ancestors to what we now know as cassoulet, pot pie and lasagna.
About 600 years later, hotdishes joined the party. Experts at Minnesota Historical Society said that the earliest written recipe for hotdish can be found in a Mankato, Minnesota, church cookbook from 1930. C. W. Anderson’s rendition called for ground beef, tomato soup, pasta and canned peas.
The 1930s turned into a momentous decade for both casseroles and hotdishes, as a growing number of home cooks relied on them as a budget-friendly way to feed a large group during the Great Depression. Plus, this is the decade during which Campbell’s debuted canned condensed cream soups.
In 1953, as a way to make the most of surplus spuds after creating French fries, the folks at Ore-Ida introduced frozen Tater Tots. Similar to how many midcentury modern casseroles called for a crushed cracker or potato chip topping, creative Midwestern cooks began crowning their hotdishes with tots.
More than 70 years later, this tasty “religion” has many apostles, and countless delicious pieces of evidence why they are worthy of worship … OK, or at least worthy of whipping up all 12 months of the year.
Still, if Andrew was forced to choose his most treasured variations on the theme, he would stick to the classics. You must make Tater Tot Hotdish, which Andrew said is “comfort food nirvana … Pull this recipe out at your next potluck, dinner party, or family reunion. I guarantee your friends will love it.” And you shouldn’t skip Tuna Noodle Casserole.
“I could write a book about this dish,” Andrew noted in The Blue Food Cookbook, where he did devote at least a page to his signature recipe. “Is there a recipe more polarizing than one for hot tuna mixed with noodles and baked? I don’t think so. Hot Tuna is one of my favorite bands, so maybe I am biased. This one is so creamy, vegetal and addictive that even tuna haters will love it.”
Here are three secrets to level up your next tuna casserole, chef-style:
- Use fresh herbs like dill, tarragon and parsley to freshen things up.
- Opt for high-quality, sustainable canned tuna packed in water instead of oil; the rest of the dish is rich enough.
- Toss buttery breadcrumbs with grated lemon zest, minced garlic and chopped parsley for a flavor-packed crunchy topping.
Interview: In The Blue Food Cookbook, Andrew Zimmern Asks Us to Go Fish
Andrew Zimmern teamed up with Barton Seaver to teach everyone how to source and prepare delicious, sustainable seafood — and he won’t stop until we can all navigate those waters with confidence.
Why Andrew Zimmern Isn't Slowing Down
The award-winning chef shares his career aspirations and his perfect day of eating.
The One Spice Every Home Cook Needs, According to Barton Seaver and Andrew Zimmern
Hint: It’s a vegetable too.
Top-Rated Casserole Recipes
The Food Network staff and readers like you are loving these five-star casserole recipes.